If you need to mischaracterise and mislead with your examples, you probably don't have a a good argument.
The equivalent C code to your other examples are:
for (i = 1; i <= 10; i++) { ... }
for (i = 20; i >= 0; i -= 2) { ... }
Your argument makes less sense when you write the counter-example out correctly, see?Of course, I can be mistaken and either there actually is a 1:1 mapping, or you meant by "1:1 mapping" something quite different from what I mean.
And? I didn't claim that all the multi-expression, body-in-the-conditional possibilities are a 1:1 mapping with sigma notation, did I?
Why do you think this is more representative of for loops in C than simpler examples I gave?
> or you meant by "1:1 mapping" something quite different from what I mean.
Well, yes. I meant that the 1:1 mapping is from sigma notation to C, not the other way around, because sigma notation was not invented after the C language.
Maybe I shouldn't have said 1:1 mapping; it's much clearer to say "The `for` loop in C is just a way to write sigma notation in programming languages".