I’m pretty sure it’s the same debate. If you distinguish between the two then it becomes a different debate. But the whole point of basic income is that everyone gets a baseline check every month, regardless of whether or how they spend it.
Even with basic income you’d still have homeless people who spent the money on things other than homes.
Yet homeless people still roam the streets and they have encampment under bridges or in subway stations.
Even maximalists safety nets don't resolve homelessness.
I don't think zero is realistic. Roaming is flexible, we talking Europe or Texas intersection? Obviously I kid, that's loaded.
So is homelessness the problem, or the most visible symptom? My 'answer' is one final question: how is this not a mental health problem, among probably others? (Clerical, procedural, etc)
I'm rambling now, but we can throw stones at people or try to help. Perfect, better, enemies
Politics and such turn everything into an xy problem. The homeless that remain aren't the ones we'd see if nothing happens.
Hell, maybe they don't see a problem. That's not really even our place to say. Nobody wins in a society. That's the idea, in a way.
Edit: the simplest answer is that every system has bad-faith participation. The ones who want a home can get one, it's 'solved', except the fringe remains... the holdouts
There's a lot of room for study here. It isn't logical, and yet. Perhaps we're "solving" the wrong thing.
Blaming homelessness on a lack of social funding is just severely misinformed. But it is a very pleasant lie, because you can then imagine that a solution actually exists "if only...".
You can look at Germany and say “they didn’t completely solve the problem so we shouldn’t try anything they are doing” or you can recognize the huge strides their efforts have made towards this complex issue, and consider how we might do the same.
See: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_Germany And: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_United_S... the statistics section
I don't know whether I am just comparing the wrong numbers or whether they count differently. But apparently Germany has much, much more homeless people.
Even the amount of sheltered people, is roughly the same in absolute terms.
You have to do it well though. In San Francisco we have homeless shelters that are so clearly alienating that people choose not to go. If you wouldn’t accept the housing we’re offering to others then it might not be a suitable solution. But if the homeless rates are much lower in Germany than in the US, it seems things like guaranteed housing probably have a lot to do with that.
Do you have evidence for that? In a comment below I listed the numbers for Germany and the US. Apparently Germany has a much bigger problem.
>Legally guaranteed housing would I think pretty clearly make a huge difference in the US.
Why? It does not put Germany above the US, in relative numbers Germany is 4x worse. Even the ratio of homeless and homeless sheltered is the same.
Go look at what Houston did. Look at what CA did.
https://www.ocregister.com/2023/07/18/something-is-clearly-o...
WE spent 42k per homeless person.
We could have rented them all apartments for the year for that price. It would have made more sense.
No, you can't. You can not give the homeless apartments and I do mean that literally. "I pay for your rent, food, water, electricity and give you money for alcohol" isn't a good enough incentive for homeless people to stop being homeless. If it were homeless people wouldn't exist here in Germany, yet they do.
They won't all take it. In particular the shelter. You can force them to suddenly be domestic or to live under someone else's rules.
> dont know why people want to see them suffer more than necessary
That's the hard part. Many of them positively take actions that make themselves suffer. Drug use in particular. If you've ever had a schizophrenic family member you know precisely this pain.
edit: was kinda replying to one of the comments further down but somehow posted as a top level. plz forgive.