News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Joining a startup: high salary, no equity OR "startup sal... by ChuckMcM on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @04:06PM (#4009691)
Interesting conversation. The answer is actually much simpler. "Never work for a salary that you can't live on." which is to say that if you are an employee of a startup you should first make sure that you can live day to day on your compensation before you talk about equity. Remember that compensation consists of salary, benefits, and vacation time. They all contribute.

Once you have that out of the way, you can think about 'extra'.

Getting the 'extra' as equity has the highest potential return and the lowest probable return. Which is to say that if the startup has an exit that involves the common stock you could potentially get millions of dollars. However startups are startups because they are as yet unproven businesses. Their chance of failure is high early on and it goes down in proportion to revenue.

What that means is that when a startup is later stage, has a product and some revenue, its less likely to fail than when it first starts and before it has a product or revenue.

So generally you can split startups into fairly large risk baskets.

Basket 1: pre-product / post-product

Startups that are pre-product are the highest risk, and the getting 'extra' as equity here is something of a sucker's bet. The company has yet to prove they can even build what it is they want to build, much less sell it or get users.

Basket 2 (post-product): pre-revenue / post-revenue

Startups that have a product can be spit into those that have convinced a customer to pay them money for their product and those that haven't. The sad truth is that some products cannot be sold profitably or at all. So the next big 'milestone' is that there is revenue coming in from customers who are using/buying the product. Pre-revenue is higher risk, post revenue lower risk.

Basket 3 (post-product, post-revenue): Traction / No Traction

The third split is the traction/no-traction split. If a startup has customers and revenue, they have crossed the 'big' hurdles, but to grow they need more customers. That is where traction comes into play. Is the startup getting new customers? What is it costing to get them? Do those costs outweigh the revenue they generate?

If your startup is post-product, post-revenue, and has traction always take equity. It is going to pay back better than salary.

Re:Joining a startup: high salary, no equity OR "startup sal... by tikhonj on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @11:00PM (#4011312)
I think your answer is perfect: make sure you're making enough not to worry about money unduly and then pick whichever one seems more fun. I find worrying too much about getting the highest expected return just isn't worth it, at least to me.