News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Students Learn as Well from Software as from Live Teachers by joe_the_user on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:01PM (#4008996)
Uh you think?

How well do you think American society and institutions were doing during the hay day of not-for-profit education versus how well do you think it's doing now? Does your criteria include providing for all citizens and having a robust public debate?

It seems more likely to me that the marketizing measures of today have done a lot to break the community building aspect of higher education but that for-profit education hardly promises anything better. Suuure, blame the government for the scams that constitute for-profit institutions now but without the student loan scheme, they wouldn't exist at all.

Re:Students Learn as Well from Software as from Live Teachers by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:48PM (#4009253)
...hay day of not-for-profit education versus how well do you think it's doing now?

Could you be more specific about what periods you are referring to? Personally, I would characterize now as the hay day of not-for-profit education - we have far more of it than ever before.

Suuure, blame the government...

Huh? I was blaming principal-agent problems in nonprofits, and suggesting they are less of an issue in for-profits (though it is still an issue even there). What does this have to do with the government?