News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by paxys on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:49AM (#40087545)
If you go in to the office and there are dozens of people sitting at your desk waving flags and having political protests and refusing to let you enter and do your job, what would you call that exactly? Is that a safe working environment? How do you think an Israeli employee in that same office would have felt on the day of the protests?

These protests don't happen in a vacuum. The entire purpose is to disrupt day to day work and make people take notice.

[dead]
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by matrix87 on Friday April 19, 2024 @03:17PM (#40090916)
would you go up to a Russian coworker and get in their face about Ukraine?

people have a right to feel at ease in the workplace. if you think that your politics come before that, you aren't mature enough to work in a professional environment

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by mandmandam on Friday April 19, 2024 @07:58PM (#40093176)
> would you go up to a Russian coworker and get in their face about Ukraine?

Is the company supplying arms to Russia? Is the coworker the boss who lied about doing so? Have the Russians killed 15,000 children in 6 months with the aid of those weapons?

Let's keep these analogies somewhat accurate.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by matrix87 on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:55PM (#40093553)
> the company

Where in my comment did I say anything about the company? GP was referring to making specific coworkers feel uncomfortable on the basis of ethnic identity

If you think your politics take precedence over having a workplace where people can be productive without feeling under threat, consider freelance work

If you disagree with your employer on such a fundamental level, maybe consider a different employer? If you leaving isn't enough to make them change their mind, what more will this degree of protesting accomplish?

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lern_too_spel on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:20PM (#40094080)
A lot of people are talking about Nimbus now. Would they be if these employees had simply quit?
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by 0xBDB on Monday April 22, 2024 @01:50PM (#40116810)
> Is the company supplying arms to Russia? Is the coworker the boss who lied about >doing so?

Is there some evidence that this is a defense/military-related project despite Google's public denials that that is the case? Honest question, I have no idea.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lp0_on_fire on Friday April 19, 2024 @01:55PM (#40089966)
Bringing your performative politics into the workplace is a problem, yes. I am 100 percent positive that if the shoe were on the other foot here, these former google employees would be screaming bloody murder.

Protest on your own time and let the rest of us do our jobs and go home to our families. This is no different than protesters blocking roads or airports. At best you get a few minutes of fame on the nightly news and at worst you end up alienating people who would otherwise be sympathetic to your cause.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by yencabulator on Friday April 19, 2024 @04:03PM (#40091380)
The question was would you feel "intimidated and threatened", not whether it's a problem or appropriate for the workplace.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lp0_on_fire on Friday April 19, 2024 @04:32PM (#40091614)
By definition something that is intimidating or threatening is inappropriate for the workplace so I don't see the point you're trying to make.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by yencabulator on Friday April 19, 2024 @04:39PM (#40091654)
Just because it might be inappropriate for the workplace does not make it intimidating or threatening. Grandparent was asking what was the intimidating and threatening part.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lp0_on_fire on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:27PM (#40092096)
How do you think an Israeli who lost a relative when Hamas murdered hundreds of innocent civilians would feel about this little stunt in the workplace?

Maybe a relative of one of the ones whose bodies were mutilated and paraded around for all to see? You don't think that might touch a nerve?

Or on the opposite shoe: What if it were a bunch of Israeli employees who occupied that office demanding that google do MORE to support the war effort?

Leave your politics out of the workplace. This is not rocket science and the phenomenon we have nowadays where _everything_ must be co-opted for the political cause-du-jour is outright exhausting, even to people who support it.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by yencabulator on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:37PM (#40092193)
Once again, the criteria was "intimidating and threatening". You and others keep dancing around that seemingly baseless statement.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lp0_on_fire on Friday April 19, 2024 @06:30PM (#40092643)
Protesting in favor/ against sensitive subjects and causing a ruckus that results in _law enforcement getting involved_ can be “intimidating and threatening” when it _happens at your workplace_.

I feel you’re being deliberately obtuse on this.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by yencabulator on Friday April 19, 2024 @06:33PM (#40092668)
As far as I read, law enforcement was there just to remove the people from the premises, not to stop violent behavior. You do realize many protests involve just sitting in place until police drags you away, and that that's intentional?
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lp0_on_fire on Friday April 19, 2024 @07:06PM (#40092897)
You realize that breaking into a private office, being asked, and then told, to leave automatically escalates a situation? Obviously they want to get arrested because they’re out for attention.

You realize there are many examples of these sit-ins lately end with protesters gluing themselves to the floor/road or damaging property, maybe toss some paint on priceless art when it happens to a museum? Or relieving themselves in place so that some poor underpaid janitor has to clean up? After the protesters smile for the camera of course.

I find that pretty intimidating because if the spoiled rich brats looking for social media points are willing to do that to themselves what else are they willing to do? Is it totally unreasonable to assume one could be stupid and end up hitting someone? In the United State where gun crime is unfortunately high?

The likelihood of this particular incident developing into that was probably pretty low but the point is that other people should not have to make that kind of mental calculus at work. They have a right not to be subjected to whatever hot button political cause is in vogue when they’re trying to go to work so they can feed themselves and their family.

If you want to protest do it on your own time on public property or your own. Don’t expect sympathy from those of us that don’t want to hear it at our place of business.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by yencabulator on Friday April 19, 2024 @07:17PM (#40092951)
I don't even disagree with you on many of those points, but you're still dancing around the actual question and just complaining that somebody dared to protest.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lp0_on_fire on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:56PM (#40093562)
You not liking my answer != me dancing around the question. If you can't glean my position on this by now there's nothing more to be had from this conversation.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by matrix87 on Friday April 19, 2024 @10:56PM (#40094326)
As a Jew, I wouldn't feel comfortable wearing a star of David or any external signal of it

I wouldn't even feel comfortable disclosing being Jewish to anyone in the workplace without getting chased down by a rabid mob chanting "free Palestine"

Nor am I obligated to qualify my own Jewishness by giving some opinion critical of the status quo

If you have difficulty coexisting with minorities in the workplace, that's your problem. We aren't obligated to put up with your shit

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by yencabulator on Friday April 19, 2024 @11:03PM (#40094380)
You also seem to dance around the very question, "wouldn't feel comfortable" is very different from "intimidated and threatened".

Here's what was asked:

> Do you have references for the “intimidated and threatened” bit? Is there a claim it went beyond a peaceful protest?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40087425

Look at this photo and tell me seriously you feel "threatened" by people sitting on the floor to protest a previously-thought-of-as-good company being a military contractor now:

https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,forma...

As a thought experiment, let's say they were protesting Google working for the French military. Or the US military. Or the South Korean military. Is the above a photo of an "intimidating and threatening" protest?

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lotsoweiners on Friday April 19, 2024 @11:21PM (#40094479)
Are the masks some lame attempt at hiding identities or is it some kind of virtue signal thing? Genuine question because I’ve probably seen 5 masks in the last 6 months and at least 2 of those were at a dentist office.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by matrix87 on Friday April 19, 2024 @11:27PM (#40094510)
You put "threatened" in quotation marks and aggressively insist on justification? You aren't entitled to one.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by throwaway44773 on Friday April 19, 2024 @02:45PM (#40090572)
The right equivalent would be a christian proselytizing to his colleagues. He’d end up with HR complaints quite quickly.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by Scarblac on Friday April 19, 2024 @01:46PM (#40089862)
Despite confident sounding statements like that, there's nowhere near consensus that genocide is being committed in this war.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by drewmcarthur on Friday April 19, 2024 @01:58PM (#40090012)
well, only if you ignore the court rulings by the ICJ
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by courseofaction on Friday April 19, 2024 @02:27PM (#40090365)
You're right, I'm confident in my analysis that this is genocide but it's an emotional and difficult argument.

Rather than get bogged in semantics, I'll settle for ethnic cleansing and argue from there: Israel has systematically displaced Palestinians with their own population for decades against international law. Israel has placed civilians in a conflict zone to occupy land.

This is not a controversial set of facts and I encourage you to follow it up. Israel is absolutely breaking international law: https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2024/03/un-human-rig... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_settlement

Israel has used civilians for military objectives in occupied land. The civilians comprise part of Israel's hostile, occupying force against the owners of the land, no?

The narrative that Hamas attacked simple peaceloving people and deserves to be crushed mercilessly is an oversimplification which ignores all context.

Despite insightful sounding statements like yours, there's nothing added to the conversation by saying 'its complicated'. You muddy the mud.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by o11c on Friday April 19, 2024 @01:47PM (#40089871)
If standing around counts as "intimidation", what does "we're going to bomb your neighborhood" count as?

This isn't theoretical.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lupusreal on Friday April 19, 2024 @02:08PM (#40090135)
So if bomb threats are intimidation, nothing short of bomb threats can also be intimidation? Explain yourself.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by o11c on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:03PM (#40091864)
Did I say that?

No, I was referring to the fact that Israel is bombing every place where Palestinians live, and Google is helping them do it.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by lupusreal on Friday April 19, 2024 @06:04PM (#40092425)
Actively bombing people, as Israel is doing, is far more than intimidation. In my view they're committing a genocide. But how does this make the other not intimidation? If you weren't implying that the other doesn't qualify as intimidation, then your comment makes zero sense.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by tonfreed on Friday April 19, 2024 @01:59PM (#40090025)
Ok, so should James Demore be reinstated? All the did was post something that no one had to even read on an internal page.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by neilk on Friday April 19, 2024 @03:12PM (#40090878)
Yes, that is perfectly safe. And obviously so.

It may be upsetting, or disruptive to work, or a firing offense, but per your description nobody was in danger.

Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by frakkingcylons on Friday April 19, 2024 @03:32PM (#40091082)
No I would not feel like my safety was threatened. I can imagine much more concerning shit than people sitting and holding signs.
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by ALittleLight on Friday April 19, 2024 @06:56PM (#40092825)
It's not about feeling like your safety is threatened physically or that you will be hurt or killed. I agree "threatened" or "safety" language is slightly out of place - but I'm not sure what the right alternative is.

The issue is, imagine you disagree with these protesters. Do you feel comfortable saying "Actually, I support Israel because X, Y, and Z. This isn't really a genocide, blah blah blah." I think most people would not feel comfortable disagreeing with a small crowd loudly protesting.

Nor should you feel comfortable, in my view, expressing that opinion at work. That opinion might make other people with contrasting opinions feel uncomfortable. It might make them hate you. Work isn't about opining on politics or current affairs, it's about, in Google's case, slightly altering your login form or cancelling products. Employees at work should focus on their jobs, or privately talk with people they are comfortable around - not really a problem if two friends and coworkers have a small political debate over lunch, more of a problem if there is a conversation imposed on unwilling participants.

The issue is that some people violate this unspoken agreement and force their political fixations on everyone else.

[dead]
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by ALittleLight on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:00PM (#40093598)
> /dev/null
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by anal_reactor on Saturday April 20, 2024 @05:49AM (#40096099)
Lol "apply water to the burnt area"
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by taskforcegemini on Wednesday April 24, 2024 @01:49AM (#40141045)
but if genocide was the goal, wouldn't Israel already be done? and isn't genocide the goal of the Palestinians (or Irans Government)?
Re:I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B I... by deanCommie on Thursday April 25, 2024 @11:52AM (#40159016)
Thank you for this comment, I think you're asking important questions.

First, let's acknowledge that "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" is a terrible strategy. There are plenty of conflicts out there at every scale where neither side has the moral highground.

It is entirely possible for both sides of a conflict to be complicit of crimes, war crimes, crimes against humanity, or genocide.

In this particular case it is absolutely the cause of Iran (and most likely Hamas, though this one has a bit more nuance) to "wipe Israel off the map", and if they could snap their fingers and kill every jew on the planet, they would.

That doesn't make the force opposing them not themselves potentially culpable. We don't excuse the US firebombing hundreds of thousands of civilians in Tokyo, or the Soviet soldiers raping their way through Germany despite the horrors of Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany.

ESPECIALLY if we deem one side our ally - they must be held to a higher standard than our enemy.

Second, the intent of crimes, and the success of crimes are independent. Being BAD at crimes doesn't make them not crimes. See: Trump, Donald.

Third, let's put this together. Israel is not bad Genocide. Israel is GOOD at Genocide because it knows that if it actually put all Palestinians into a Nazi-like concentration camp they would lose the support of the entire world. Which is why much as their other enemy Russia, they apply Salami Tactics (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salami_slicing_tactics) to gradually erode the civil rights of palestenians (especially in the West Bank) by making their life more and more unpalatable and not care what ultimately happens to them (so long as they don't strike out back at Israel; and in some cases even if they do because that allows them to go in and dramatically overreact)

Remember, "Genocide" is not "Extermination of an entire ethnicity in a gas chamber", there are many sub-definitions of it. I'm not gonna get pedantic about it though. Israel is conducting a purposeful (via apathy/lack of care) massacre of Palestinian civilians under the guise of exterminating Hamas. That this is happening is not in dispute. The only thing that's in dispute among the mainstream is whether whether these costs to civilian lives are justified for the greater cause (much as people defend the WW2 concepts I mentioned above).

And if the entire context was "In October, Hamas struck out at Israel killing thousands of Jewish civilians, so now Hamas must be removed no matter what the cost", I could at least conceive of an intellectual argument of how many dead Palestinians is fair to take reprisal for dead Jews.

But that's not the start of this, and that's not the full context, and I hope at least everyone on hackernews reading this knows that.