Re:Why Ukraine Is Losing the War
by firsttime844 on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:45PM
(#40082684)
My understanding is that the western arms manufacturing base is being out-produced by that of Russia. So even if funding is approved by the U.S. the end result will not change. This is evidenced, for example, by the loan of shells from Korea to the U.S.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Russia is getting shells from Korea too, though. That's not convincing evidence of anything in particular IMO, except that neither Korean regime is planning to go to war imminently and the Russo-Ukrainian war is eating up a lot of shells.
That said there is a lot of other credible evidence that Russia's defense industrial base (DIB) is ramping up. Russia is in a full war-economy mode, while western nations have many other priorities. Whether they can keep it up, and whether the West starts ramping up more, we'll see.
Re:Why Ukraine Is Losing the War
by s1artibartfast on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:37PM
(#40082940)
I dont think that Russia has actually instituted a true war economy, which is usually a pretty high bar.
Re:Why Ukraine Is Losing the War
by s1artibartfast on Friday April 19, 2024 @12:14AM
(#40083371)
NY times was pay walled, but the others showed little understanding of what a fully mobilized war economy is. You can have wage freezes, job freezes, rationing, and harsh Market controls. Russia has only done these things to a very limited degree. Few countries have been fully mobilized since World War II
Re:Why Ukraine Is Losing the War
by justinclift on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:37PM
(#40082939)
> Russia is getting shells from Korea ...
North Korea yeah? There are two different nations with "Korea" in their name, with radically different approaches to the world.
Not sure why you think I don't know this. My comment contains the phrase "neither Korean regime".
Re:Why Ukraine Is Losing the War
by justinclift on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:29PM
(#40082903)
Doesn't seem like it's just Russia who's producing arms for the other side: :(
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/china-is-giving-russia-...
The swiss newspaper NZZ reported in february that the cost for a drone, out of russian ( licensed-) production - i believe the site that has been attacked recently - is 27.000 EUR per unit. A german/french/british artillary unit costs 500-650-k EUR. Which allows for roughly 25-missed drone attacks against one artillery unit and with the 26-th attempt beeing a hit, the damage/cost on the ukrainian side still remains higher than the cost spent by the russian attacker. That tells me, that the idea of the western supporters of ukraine, to win the war by economically outperforming russia simply does not work. Its not like in the 1940-ies when the US war-economy outperformed the german war-industries.
One more reason for more efforts to negotiate a end of this conflict, the sooner the better.