News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by koolba on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:23PM (#40082536)
You’re forgetting that the people living in those towns don’t want you to suddenly increase the housing stock by 5x and with it the class sizes.

Why should a minority of people, especially those that don’t even live in these towns, dictate how the town will be changing?

If dense housing is the bees knees, make people want to live in cities.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:51PM (#40082717)
> You’re forgetting that the people living in those towns don’t want you to suddenly increase the housing stock by 5x and with it the class sizes.

It's actually easier to have smaller class sizes with higher density because you spend less on transportation and real estate and can use the money hire more teachers, or lower your taxes, or do whatever you like with it.

> Why should a minority of people, especially those that don’t even live in these towns, dictate how the town will be changing?

Because it's every town operating under the same set of incentives. Existing homeowners don't want more housing because they want the value of their existing home to go up through scarcity. It's the same in every town, so if you want to build "cities" anywhere the decision on whether it can be done in a particular place can't be solely in the hands of the people who have the financial incentive to say no.

> If dense housing is the bees knees, make people want to live in cities.

If people didn't want to live in cities then why does the housing there cost more?

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by koolba on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:33PM (#40082919)
> It's actually easier to have smaller class sizes with higher density because you spend less on transportation and real estate and can use the money hire more teachers, or lower your taxes, or do whatever you like with it.

In practice, new housing increases the denominator (number of students) more the than numerator (tax dollars). This is because the existing tax base includes non-residential land that only provides tax dollars without increase school costs. So any new housing is always a net loss.

> Existing homeowners don't want more housing because they want the value of their existing home to go up through scarcity.

The flip side of that is that people who don’t have those houses want to take that away without paying the market price for that land.

> If people didn't want to live in cities then why does the housing there cost more?

Historicaly, being close to high paying jobs was a major driver. There’s also an annual resupply of starry eyed graduates.

Though I’ll be honest to not understand why anyone would pay a premium to live like a sardine. The air quality alone is enough reason to move out of the city.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @03:59AM (#40084382)
> In practice, new housing increases the denominator (number of students) more the than numerator (tax dollars). This is because the existing tax base includes non-residential land that only provides tax dollars without increase school costs. So any new housing is always a net loss.

The assumption here is that you would have only new residential housing. But zoning that allows for higher density construction also allows for new businesses that pay taxes and have no children.

And in order to say "always" you would have to be making some assumptions about the ratio of taxes paid to number of kids. But the people who move into small cheap apartments and condos are most often college students and retirees, who don't have kids yet (and wouldn't continue to live there if they did) or their kids are already grown. Then you get new tax dollars but no new students. Whereas the people who can afford a 3- or 4-bedroom unit have money and pay an above-average amount of tax, so they might have kids but they're paying their own way.

A focus on ratios is also misguided because many expenses are fixed costs. If you have twice as many people you don't need e.g. twice as many roads because most single-lane roads are nowhere near capacity, so it's really the opposite: You get their tax revenue and then get to amortize all of your fixed costs over a larger tax base. Moreover, if someone is paying $25,000/year in taxes and then their being in the area requires the government to spend $20,000/year on services for them, you've got a net gain of $5000 from their presence regardless of what the ratio is for some other person or existing residents.

> The flip side of that is that people who don’t have those houses want to take that away without paying the market price for that land.

They are paying the market price for that land. In order to build a multi-story building, you first have to buy a piece of land to put it on.

What they're doing is making more efficient use of that land, by creating e.g. 10 housing units on a lot currently being used for 1. That reduces the market price of housing units by supply and demand, but the higher price was only ever a result of artificial scarcity.

> Historicaly, being close to high paying jobs was a major driver.

So in other words, a shorter commute makes up for a higher price. But if you prohibit housing construction, this trade off gets even worse. The job is in the city, you could have lived in a 6-unit building 20 minutes away, but if those are prohibited then you need 6 times as much land for the same number of residents and now they either have to pay more even for the 20 minute commute or take the far away housing with a 60+ minute commute.

> Though I’ll be honest to not understand why anyone would pay a premium to live like a sardine.

Density and small units are not inherently associated. You can put 4000 sq ft units in a multi-story building and still have ten times the density of a single-family home of half the size as one unit.

> The air quality alone is enough reason to move out of the city.

Tell that to the suburban ignoramuses who think it's a good idea to burn wood:

https://www.familiesforcleanair.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/...

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by jjav on Friday April 19, 2024 @03:44AM (#40084332)
> If people didn't want to live in cities then why does the housing there cost more?

Density seems to always make an area more expensive. What are the two densest cities in the US? Which are the two most expensive cities in the US?

Increasing density does not ever seem to make an area cheaper to live. Maybe that is ok, but it does contradict the idea of building more to make it cheaper.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @04:09AM (#40084434)
> Density seems to always make an area more expensive. What are the two densest cities in the US? Which are the two most expensive cities in the US?

The causation goes the other way. When an area has a lot of housing demand, that's where they put the tall buildings. Nobody is going to build a skyscraper in the middle of a corn field.

But in order for the density to keep up with demand, you can't suppress new construction.

> What are the two densest cities in the US? Which are the two most expensive cities in the US?

Which are the two cities in the US with the most restrictive zoning and building codes? Which are the two most expensive cities in the US?

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by alistairSH on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:14AM (#40085808)
But in practice, we're so far behind on the supply side that we could densify much of our cities and inner suburbs and still see values rise. And I'm not convinced that when done in a playful manner, that densification doesn't add value to existing SFHs, despite now being located in a noisier/denser/whatever area. People largely prefer convenience and not driving all the time. Just walking to school is a huge plus - fewer noisy buses, more healthy kids, etc.

Arlington VA added a ton of mid-rise and high-rise development in the 80s/90s (Clarendon, Courthouse, Ballston) with good results. Reston VA is now doing the same and home that were $400k a decade ago are selling for nearly double. In both cases, the scope of in-fill was tightly controlled - the local governments created dense zones around the Metro stations - which makes sense.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @01:59PM (#40090026)
> But in practice, we're so far behind on the supply side that we could densify much of our cities and inner suburbs and still see values rise.

This is a common source of confusion. If you relax zoning, the instantaneous effect is that the value of land is increased in the areas where the zoning is made more permissive (because now you can do more with the land) and reduced where zoning was already permissive (because now land zoned for those uses is less scarce).

So the immediate effect is that the value of the land where single-family homes are will go up, and that effect is permanent. Then the value of indoor space goes down as people are allowed to and do build more of it. Which is what we're after, because the important thing is that people can get a couple thousand sq ft of living space for an affordable price, regardless of the number of floors the building they're in has. If the value of the land doubles but the amount of housing per acre quintuples, you've still made the land cost per housing unit decline by 250%.

What that does to the long-term value of existing single-family homes depends on how much demand there is. In areas where the zoning had been oppressively restrictive, the gain in land value from relaxing the zoning could exceed the amount that it's even possible to lose from the value of indoor space.

For example, you have a $400,000 house and the new zoning makes the land itself worth $500,000, but housing still becomes more affordable because someone can buy that $500,000 piece of land, build a dozen housing units there and sell the property for $2.4M, pricing each of the units at $200,000. The existing single family home still sells for $500,000+ though, not because it's a housing unit but because it's an acre of land where someone could build a dozen.

> In both cases, the scope of in-fill was tightly controlled - the local governments created dense zones around the Metro stations - which makes sense.

It doesn't. It makes a significant amount of sense to put a 3-5 story building in an area with mostly single-family homes, because that can often be supported with no additional infrastructure. If you want to put them all in the same place then you have to upgrade the utilities and transportation infrastructure there. Which is fine if that's what happens naturally because people choose to develop a particular area, but there is no reason to force it.

And trying to concentrate them all in one area also slows down the construction and makes it cost more, because then the land cost there remains high for lack of alternatives, forcing developers to buy out those particular people (and giving them undue gains that should have been evenly distributed to the community at large) instead of buying whatever properties were already on the market.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by jjav on Friday April 19, 2024 @06:16PM (#40092520)
> build a dozen housing units there and sell the property for $2.4M, pricing each of the units at $200,000

If builders were selling units at their cost plus a fixed profit margin, you're right.

But builders are in the business of maximizing profit. If in this area there was a backlog of people willing to pay 400K for a housing unit, the builder will sell each of these dozen units for 400K.

If you feel I'm wrong, please point me at a few cities in the US where housing became cheaper as density increased.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:25PM (#40093324)
Well you have to pick one. Either people will pay ~$400K for the units and then the builder's incentive to build there is obvious -- because there is enough demand to sell them for $400K, which is profitable.

Or people wouldn't pay quite as much as the existing single-family homes, but they'd still pay more than the builder's costs to construct the building, so it's still profitable. It only becomes not profitable when the price of a housing unit drops below the builder's costs. Which is why they'd want to keep building until that happens.

> If you feel I'm wrong, please point me at a few cities in the US where housing became cheaper as density increased.

I keep saying this. The causation goes the other way. Density increases where demand is higher. Higher demand increases prices, then density blunts the increase so that it's smaller than it would be if no additional construction occurred. That doesn't mean it would become cheaper in the higher demand area than the lower demand area -- particularly if the area is still growing, in which case construction lags the increase in demand and has to catch up. And if construction is inhibited, it can't, so you get as much density as the zoning allows and then prices skyrocket because supply can no longer respond to increases in demand. Which can happen even if the area already has above-average density.

What you'd need to see a price decrease is an area where zoning was relaxed after being strict, allowing density to increase after it had previously been suppressed, so that density increases because of the legal change rather than a new increase in demand. But the lack of this happening in areas of high demand is exactly the problem. Maybe we should try it and see what happens?

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by jjav on Friday April 19, 2024 @06:07PM (#40092443)
> The causation goes the other way. When an area has a lot of housing demand, that's where they put the tall buildings. Nobody is going to build a skyscraper in the middle of a corn field.

I believe it's a feedback loop really, not exclusively in one direction or the other.

You're right that nobody wants to build a skyscraper out in the farmlands. They build it in the city, which makes that city a tiny bit more dense, pulls in more people and makes the city a small increment more attractive and pulls in even more people which in turn raises prices even more and the cycle continues. As cities get more dense they always get more expensive.

Look at Manhattan, full of highrises and skyscrapers as far as the eye can see, and is the #1 most expensive area in the US to live.

> Which are the two cities in the US with the most restrictive zoning and building codes?

I have no idea to be honest. Do you have info on that?

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @07:04PM (#40092877)
> They build it in the city, which makes that city a tiny bit more dense, pulls in more people and makes the city a small increment more attractive and pulls in even more people which in turn raises prices even more and the cycle continues. As cities get more dense they always get more expensive.

This is only a feedback loop if the city becomes more attractive by a larger amount than the increase in housing. For example, if you add new housing for 1000 people and this causes 1200 new people to move to the city. If adding new housing for 1000 people causes 800 new people to move to the city, you've still created more new housing for locals than you had before, and can just keep at it.

We can use basic math to see that even if the former ever happens, it can't sustainably happen. If e.g. the Chicago Metro area had the population density of Manhattan, it would have a larger population than the United States as a whole, 750M vs. 333M. A single metropolitan area could provide more housing than there are people to live in it. That many people would have to exist before they could move there. And obviously the entire US population is not going to move to a single metro area anyway, so you would reach saturation long before that.

Now, one thing that does happen is that tall buildings are more expensive to build, so when you get into the extremely high densities like in Manhattan, part of the high cost is the construction cost for a building that tall. But Manhattan is an outlier. If we're talking about converting single family homes into 12-unit condos, the cost per unit isn't much different and you get a 12X increase in density.

And here's another piece of the puzzle: Where are these people coming from? If you build new housing in New York, that might attract people who used to live in Boston. If you build new housing in Boston, that might attract people who used to live in Seattle. What happens if you build new housing in New York and Boston and Seattle and Los Angels etc.? If people move from everywhere to everywhere, there is no net migration and no increase in local demand. And even if you did only increase the amount of housing in New York, and that caused people to move to New York from Boston and Seattle and Los Angeles, then housing would become more affordable in Boston and Seattle and Los Angeles because the local demand there would go down. So you're talking about a hyper-local effect, whereas on a question of national policy, supply and demand is in full effect and "build more housing" makes the average unit cost less even if the ones that get more affordable aren't in the same place as the ones you build.

> I have no idea to be honest. Do you have info on that?

It's the same two cities. It's New York and San Francisco. They both make it extremely arduous to add new housing. Many of the existing buildings in Manhattan would be illegal to build today. SF is even worse.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by jjav on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:46PM (#40093870)
> We can use basic math

The math checks out on paper, the arguments make sense.

And yet, whenever I see a very dense city, I also see an extremely expensive place to live.

When observations contradict theory, I have to think there's some flaw in the theory.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday April 20, 2024 @04:33PM (#40100791)
The observations are entirely consistent with the theory.

Suppose you have an area with 10,000 acres of land and local demand for 250 housing units, i.e. a rural location. Housing here is going to be inexpensive; land is not scarce so people will build a hundred single family homes on a hundred acres of land, there will still be 9750 acres available and the main cost will be the cost of constructing a house.

Now suppose you have the same 10,000 acres of land but local demand for 25,000 housing units. In the absence of zoning restrictions, this will still result in somewhat higher prices. Many of the lots will need more than one housing unit, these may cost a little more to build, and the cost of the land will be a little higher because there is more demand. In the presence of zoning restrictions requiring only single family homes on an acre of land, you're completely screwed, because the maximum number of units you can build is 10,000 and you have demand for 25,000. We see the latter in practice in many places, e.g. places where any single family home with an acre of land is selling for more than a million dollars.

Now suppose you have the same 10,000 acres of land but local demand for 250,000 housing units. It is not only not possible to satisfy this demand without multi-story buildings, it will take tall ones at that. Without any restrictions that is what would happen, and prices would be a little higher for the same reasons, but still be kept in check by new construction. However, if zoning only allows 125,000 units to be built, you would have a significant amount of density and still fall well short of the 250,000 you need, causing prices to be much higher.

The prices in the area where you need 25 units per acre are always going to be higher, but there is a difference between "higher because it costs somewhat more to construct a 10 story building" and "San Francisco prices".

Moreover, there is another reason why the highest density areas have such high prices. Common zoning practice is to assign some very small area where the tallest buildings can be constructed, e.g. here's the NYC zoning site:

https://zola.planning.nyc.gov

Have a look at what proportion of the land is zoned R8-R10, allowing for the sort of densities seen in Manhattan. It's only allowed where it already is. It's not even allowed in all of Manhattan, which itself is less than 1% of the New York Metro area. So if you want to build a very tall building, it has to be in that tiny sliver in Manhattan, causing the price of land with that zoning to be astronomical because it's so artificially scarce, and adding that cost to the price of any housing there. You keep asking why housing costs so much in Manhattan -- that's why, because you're not allowed to build those buildings somewhere else, and the price of land operates on supply and demand. What's happening is exactly as the theory predicts: Artificial scarcity raises prices.

Or to ask your question in reverse, show me a place with a large amount of land area under permissive zoning that has higher housing costs than NYC or SF.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by jjav on Sunday April 21, 2024 @02:00AM (#40103476)
> Or to ask your question in reverse, show me a place with a large amount of land area under permissive zoning that has higher housing costs than NYC or SF.

Ultimately, the question I find most interesting is: Which cities have achieved very high density while maintaining a low cost of living (relative to local salaries)?

We can debate "If only they did ..." forever, but if there are no actual cities where this has ever happened, maybe the answer is that it can't happen.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by davidw on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:29PM (#40082582)
This attitude is why we have a housing crisis. Not banks or Blackstone, not RealPage, not foreign buyers, not short term rentals. Those things may not help, but the lid on the housing supply are people in your city who, ironically, generally are a small but involved minority who show up to say NO to housing and NO to a diversity of housing types.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by dghlsakjg on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:34PM (#40082608)
Conversely: why should my neighbor get to dictate if I get to build a duplex on my property.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by koolba on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:22PM (#40082871)
Same reason you have a say in whether there’s a strip mine or a landfill across the street from your property. The residents come together and decide on the rules by which they will be governed.

Just because they don’t jive with exactly how you’d want things doesn’t mean the system is not working as it’s intended.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by secstate on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:49PM (#40083011)
But that's a silly example, because proving net-harm from industrial uses across from residential is easy. Proving net-harm from denser residential is generally an exercise in NIMBY-ism that slides very smoothly into classism and racism about who would live in those denser units.

Residents coming together to decide on rules by which they are governed can get us public lynching too. It doesn't mean it's good governance.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by koolba on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:05PM (#40083085)
The example is meant to be silly to demonstrate that there’s clearly some limit of what is acceptable and it’s the stricter intersection of every level of government within the bounds of what’s constitutional. One of those levels is the local government consisting of the people that already live in a municipality.

There’s no inherent right, whether constitutionally granted or innately, for you to build whatever you’d like, wherever you’d like. Just like I can’t go build a shack in the middle of NYC’s Central Park.

Framing it as racism or classism is a sign that you don’t have any other valid arguments. It’s literally just an excuse for a land grab!

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @05:11AM (#40084698)
> The example is meant to be silly to demonstrate that there’s clearly some limit of what is acceptable

But you can use sensible rules for this like "does this impose a significant negative externality" that neatly allow you to exclude a landfill from a residential area but not a new residential building.

> and it’s the stricter intersection of every level of government within the bounds of what’s constitutional.

The entire question is what those laws should be. For example, should states or federal lawmakers prevent towns from imposing restrictive zoning rules, as permitted under their various constitutions?

> There’s no inherent right, whether constitutionally granted or innately, for you to build whatever you’d like, wherever you’d like. Just like I can’t go build a shack in the middle of NYC’s Central Park.

You can't go build a shack in Central Park because you don't own the land in Central Park. The issue here is when you do own the land and all you want to do is build housing during a housing shortage.

> Framing it as racism or classism is a sign that you don’t have any other valid arguments.

Only if you don't present any other valid arguments.

Also, "this is racism or classism" can be a valid argument when it is in fact racism or classism. Just because it's massively overused doesn't mean it's never actually true.

> It’s literally just an excuse for a land grab!

The proposal does not involve the use of eminent domain.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by pandaman on Friday April 19, 2024 @07:34AM (#40085496)
>But you can use sensible rules for this like "does this impose a significant negative externality" that neatly allow you to exclude a landfill from a residential area but not a new residential building.

This is exactly what the planning commissions use. Apparently the separation is not as neat as you believe.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @01:30PM (#40089641)
Oh, I see the problem. It's implied that in order to be prohibited, a negative externality should be a net harm. For example, you need to prohibit someone from taking a $1 gain by causing $10 in harm to someone else, causing a net loss of $9 to society.

Compare: You are prohibited from manufacturing electric cars by dumping heavy metals in the river, because that poisons people which causes more harm than disposing of them properly, vs. you are prohibited from manufacturing electric cars because it would reduce the profits of Exxon, ICE automakers and mechanics through increased competition and efficiency, which is not a net harm at all because it creates a countervailing benefit to consumers in a similar amount.

"It makes housing more affordable" is not a net harm.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by pandaman on Friday April 19, 2024 @03:05PM (#40090788)
Many people tried to come up with an ethical calculus through history, and while themselves believed their systems were rational and common sense, other people invariably rejected those.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @06:10PM (#40092469)
You're talking about something else entirely.

One is, how do you compare the values of e.g. pollution vs. job creation? What's the monetary value of a human life? You can try to make an estimate but there is no objective answer or unambiguous line.

The other is, there is a cartel charging monopoly rents because there is a law inhibiting anyone new from entering the market. There is a proposal to get rid of the law. By any plausible estimation the net benefits of removing the law are positive, but the cartel claims they'd be harmed because they couldn't charge monopoly rents anymore and then they'd make less money. This is not the same problem; this is the cartel objectively wanting to create a net loss for the general public in exchange for a net gain for themselves only.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by pandaman on Friday April 19, 2024 @07:28PM (#40093013)
>One is, how do you compare the values of e.g. pollution vs. job creation?

My question exactly. Ethical calculus you propose should be able to do that in a manner that won't cause affected people to literally tar and feather you in the best case.

>The other is, there is a cartel charging monopoly rents because there is a law inhibiting anyone new from entering the market.

That's like, your opinion. Fact is that you can build dense housing in any big city in the US. No cartel and no laws forbid it. The argument of "but I want an apartment tower right THERE and it's zoned SFH!!!1!" could as well be applied to SFH and with the same veracity you could repeat that "the law forbids building SFHs" because there are lots zoned AG or industrial where you cannot build a SFH.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:08PM (#40093232)
> That's like, your opinion.

That's what the law says. You own a piece of property, you want to get into the market by building more housing on it than currently exists, you can't.

> Fact is that you can build dense housing in any big city in the US. No cartel and no laws forbid it.

Explicitly prohibiting something and purposely using the law to render it uneconomical are de facto equivalent.

> The argument of "but I want an apartment tower right THERE and it's zoned SFH!!!1!" could as well be applied to SFH and with the same veracity you could repeat that "the law forbids building SFHs" because there are lots zoned AG or industrial where you cannot build a SFH.

Okay, so let's do that too. There is no good reason to prohibit single family homes in the most permissively zoned areas -- maybe the agriculture or industrial workers would prefer a shorter commute.

But also, this is often already the case. The farmer is allowed to build a farm house. There is no valid reason to prohibit it. It's just not going to happen very often whether you prohibit it or not because there is no demand for a SFH development in the middle of a large block of farmland or a bunch of warehouses and factories.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by pandaman on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:25PM (#40093328)
>That's what the law says.

Which law says there is a landlord cartel and building apartments is illegal? We both know there is no such law.

>You own a piece of property, you want to get into the market by building more housing on it than currently exists, you can't.

Is this also in some law? Which one, please be specific. How come people get in and out leasing market all the time? An apartment building near where I live changed ownership recently, I would appreciate the exact law you are referring to, this could be a crime in progress.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:36PM (#40093414)
> Which law says there is a landlord cartel and building apartments is illegal? We both know there is no such law.

We both know that it's zoning laws that prohibit land that currently contains a single family home from containing any structure with a larger number of housing units.

> How come people get in and out leasing market all the time? An apartment building near where I live changed ownership recently, I would appreciate the exact law you are referring to, this could be a crime in progress.

Buying or selling existing units doesn't increase supply.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by pandaman on Friday April 19, 2024 @09:01PM (#40093606)
>We both know that it's zoning laws that prohibit land that currently contains a single family home from containing any structure with a larger number of housing units.

Yes, but what about cartels and other stuff? Zoning does not mean there is a cartel nor does it mean you cannot build apartments.

> Buying or selling existing units doesn't increase supply.

Sure, but you said it's illegal to get into the market so I was curious what law you had in mind, as an upright citizen I wanted to report a crime, as I understand you don't know what law you had been referencing when making the previous statement?

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday April 20, 2024 @03:42PM (#40100364)
> Yes, but what about cartels and other stuff? Zoning does not mean there is a cartel nor does it mean you cannot build apartments.

Laws can be the mechanism a cartel uses for enforcement. This is called regulatory capture. The incumbents capture the regulators and have them pass laws to restrict supply and create barriers to entry.

The zoning laws restrict supply and create barriers to entry.

> Sure, but you said it's illegal to get into the market so I was curious what law you had in mind, as an upright citizen I wanted to report a crime, as I understand you don't know what law you had been referencing when making the previous statement?

Suppose that Samsung, Micron and SK Hynix have formed a price fixing cartel. If Hynix was bought out by, say, Oracle, who then does nothing to increase production, how would this imply that there isn't a cartel? Buying out an existing member of the cartel doesn't increase supply or lower prices.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by pandaman on Saturday April 20, 2024 @08:39PM (#40102302)
You keep repeating "laws do that" but never mentioned any particular law, is not this a time for you to stop and think a little bit, how is this possible that such intrusive laws remain hidden even from you?
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday April 21, 2024 @01:21AM (#40103346)
It's these laws right here:

https://zola.planning.nyc.gov

The ones that say only a tiny sliver of the city is zoned R8 through R10 (allowing for the tallest buildings), and those places already have them.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by MarkSweep on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:43PM (#40082667)
It is a reasonable concern. So reasonable in fact that everyone has it and thus the natural state of things is American cities all try to ban dense housing. Hence the housing crisis.

This is the logic behind some states like California trying to reduce the amount of local control over how dense housing can be. It is a state-wide problem that every city is disincentivized to solve.

While you were probably using hyperbole, I don’t think it’s easy to 5x the population of a city with infill housing. Just financing, land acquisition, demolition, construction, and sales takes a while. Government redtape only adds more time.

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by lotsoweiners on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:08PM (#40082797)
If you’re trying to 5x the population of any city with a housing cost issue then I suppose you are going to have a lot more problems than housing.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by alistairSH on Friday April 19, 2024 @08:10AM (#40085785)
Do we really need to 5x the population? Or would adding a studio apt to the basement of every SFH solve it (not saying this should be the solution, just thinking scope of problem)?

FWIW, I spent a few weeks working remote/vacationing in Cape Canaveral, FL two years ago (the town, not the military base). It has mixed housing - SFHs, duplex, and two-story (~8 unit) apartment blocks - it seemed to work well. It felt like a place I could happily live (other than the heat).

Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by adgjlsfhk1 on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:34PM (#40082606)
increasing housing stock doesn't increase class size. some of the extra people you get are teachers and so the school hires more teachers and runs more classes.
Re:Rents Are the Fed's 'Biggest Stumbling Block' in Taming U... by redserk on Thursday April 18, 2024 @09:29PM (#40082575)
Everyone was new to their town at some point.