There were times when I felt that too, but nowadays I predominantly use turbo. It's probably because turbo is faster and cheaper, but in lmsys turbo has 100 elo higher than original, so by and large people simply find turbo to be....better?
Nevertheless, I do wonder if not just in benchmarks but in how people use LLMs, intelligence is somewhat under utilised, or possibly offset by other qualities.
Since price influences my calculus, I can't say this for sure, but it seems being slightly smarter is not much of an edge, because it's still dumb by human standards. For most non-coding use the smart doesn't make much difference (like summarisation), I find that cheaper options like mistral-large do just as good as Opus.
In the last month I have used Command R+ more and more. Finally had some excuse to write some function calling stuff. I have also been highly impressed by Gemini Pro 1.5 finding technical answers from a dense 650 page pdf manual. I have enjoyed chatting with the WizardLM2 fine-tune for the past few days.
Somehow I haven't quite found a consistent use case for Opus.