News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by fnordpiglet on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:15AM (#40077105)
I think more likely a AI kill bot drone will be the way we die. You can build ten for the cost of one fire and forget missile, and it will be a lot more precise only killing the humans and leaving the infrastructure intact.
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by amluto on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:22AM (#40077186)
What, exactly, is the difference between an “AI kill bot drone” and a missile?
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by numpad0 on Thursday April 18, 2024 @12:13PM (#40077714)
US Export control frameworks managed to keep missile technologies from reimplemented by bored teenagers while actual guided munition technology were left stalling for decades(for better or worse - Ukraine is running out of SAMs daily), resulting in media narrative disconnect between those.
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by fnordpiglet on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:55AM (#40077507)
I can drop a cluster bomb filled with drones into a city, army base, factory and they kill everyone with precision and are collectively almost unstoppable.

Yes flying a large drone a few hundred miles over enemy fortifications is quite stoppable compared to a hypersonic missile. So, don’t do that.

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by davemp on Thursday April 18, 2024 @12:33PM (#40077998)
> I can drop a cluster bomb filled with drones into a city, army base, factory and they kill everyone with precision and are collectively almost unstoppable.

Citation needed.

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by hackerlight on Thursday April 18, 2024 @03:28PM (#40079859)
Defensive laser weapon
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by salad-tycoon on Thursday April 18, 2024 @08:43PM (#40082290)
Lasers rays? More like a ray of failure. Shift your spectrum, Microwaves are in and lasers are out.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39873977 And

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/new-microwave-wea...

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by harshreality on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:56AM (#40077527)
Reusability, good maneuverability, range, loiter time.

Something to close the gap to dispense cheaper munitions than long-range guided missiles. And to do so with a dramatically faster OODA loop.

Flying sausages with rocket motors and stubby wings don't do very well by most metrics.

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by uoaei on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:25AM (#40077220)
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:38AM (#40077333)
While a compelling short film, those tiny quadcopters are handicapped missiles. They fly slowly enough that modern anti-drone systems could engage them; their use of visual sensors leaves them vulnerable to laser blinding. Self-destructing drones are missiles trading manoeuvrability for speed.
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by 0171481 on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:49AM (#40077452)
Tiny missiles which are practically cost-free compared to conventional weapons, difficult to track by your enemies, and not just difficult to take out of the air, but oftentimes several orders of magnitude more expensive than the drone itself. Part of their effectiveness lies in the economic asymmetry involved.
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by fnordpiglet on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:59AM (#40077553)
Yes in the recent Iran attack on Israel the interceptors cost about $3mm each and the drones range from $20k to $2k. That asymmetry leads to a calculus of attack through overwhelming mass that’s so vast it’s impractical if not impossible to resist it.

https://www.businessinsider.com/suicide-drones-much-cheaper-...

https://www.politico.com/news/2023/12/19/missile-drone-penta...

https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/israel-iran-strikes-live-co...

In fact the US DoD is already proposing a “hellscape” capability this is precisely built around this idea as the primary method of countering China in the future.

https://www.defenseone.com/technology/2023/08/hellscape-dod-...

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by 0171481 on Thursday April 18, 2024 @12:14PM (#40077725)
Same thing happening in Ukraine. I actually think this is one of the huge stories that almost nobody is talking about right now. Sudden paradigm shift means big changes can happen quickly.

You have a fantastic username btw.

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday April 18, 2024 @01:18PM (#40078515)
> stories that almost nobody is talking about right now

It is being talked about non-stop in military and international relations news. The point isn’t that drones are being ignored. It is that self-destructing drones are best thought of as a new niche of missile, one that is cheaper and more manoeuvrable than a conventional missile at the expense of speed. (As opposed to drones' traditional framing as tiny planes.)

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by dgroshev on Thursday April 18, 2024 @02:09PM (#40079029)
They aren't free. Autonomy is computationally and sensor hungry, and consumes a lot of power. The moment a platform approaches the capabilities you are thinking of, it stops being cheap and stops being small. All while those drones are stopped by doors, curtains, strong wind, any kind of mist or darkness (unless you use thermal vision, which is $$$), or rain.
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by fnordpiglet on Thursday April 18, 2024 @04:11PM (#40080213)
Thermal vision isn’t particularly expensive (I can get a high resolution compact IR camera for less than $20 on AliExpress now) and turkey is already fielding AI loitering munitions that are fully autonomous. Drones with weapons aren’t stopped by curtains or doors, and modern drones aren’t stopped by winds. I can fly my consumer DJI on a day with strong winds just fine.

I think you’re underestimating the rate of change in the technology and cost space along every one of these dimensions. Your assessment was true 5 years ago, isn’t true now, and will seem anachronistic in another 5.

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by dgroshev on Thursday April 18, 2024 @04:26PM (#40080364)
The context of my reply is that "slaughterbot" short video, not 100kg+ drones.

It goes both ways. Just half a century years ago plenty of people were convinced we'd be having flying cars by now, projecting the speed of progress in one particular area forward. It doesn't work like that, progress in any given area is S-shaped, not exponential.

It's even worse when processes are adversarial. Where are the TB2s in Ukraine? Are you aware that FPV drones seem to have less than 10% success ratio nowadays?

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by fnordpiglet on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:00PM (#40082754)
My DJI weighs about 1kg and I could put explosives and enough compute on it for less than 100g to be self guided and lethal today, as well as cover every other dimension you mentioned.

The problem with flying cars is the physics at that time wasn’t conceivable (but is now it’s just I’m practically useless). The technology exists to do everything discussed by a DIY effort. It’s not about some quantum leap in ability. It’s about scale, cost reduction, and improvement of existing tooling and tying it all together. Which militaries world wide are -already- doing.

A 10% success ratio when the munition costs an order or two magnitude less is a winning proposition. The key isn’t each drone being successful it’s about launching 100,000 drones at once and being unstoppable en masse

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by aspenmayer on Thursday April 18, 2024 @10:49PM (#40083009)
> 100,000 drones at once

This is already theoretically possible with multiple teams using current technology. Intel has been doing these drone light shows for a while now, and here's a video from 2 years ago with only 1000 drones.

I wonder if the person cuing the launch at the beginning of the video understands what "drop[ping] the hammer" is a reference to. Maybe this is a case of unintentional Chekhov's gun?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chekhov's_gun

There's a whole playlist of these on Intel's YouTube channel:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bAlVweZ4dqQ&list=PLk2sjg_-F-...

Even more Intel drone videos:

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLk2sjg_-F-MftRXx0mAnA...

Oh yeah, they also have another video, where they break their own record for their Guinness world record show with 2018 drones. That's the number of drones and the year they did it in. That's already 5 years+ ago. They let slip that their drone coordination software was literally designed to control "limitless amount of drones" and it's only using a single PC for coordination.

I agree with everything you've said, in case it wasn't clear.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwQ31-vSgfs&list=PLk2sjg_-F-...

https://www.intc.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/142/i...

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by fnordpiglet on Friday April 19, 2024 @12:28AM (#40083430)
I’d also note at $2000 a drone a 100,000 drone attack would only cost $200,000,000 or half of the defense Israel mounted against 300 drones.
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by dgroshev on Friday April 19, 2024 @04:50AM (#40084606)
Your DJI can't cope with doors. 100g of explosives don't do much, see Ukraine where this was attempted multiple times with very limited effect. And most importantly, your DJI enjoys massive subsidy because it is mass produced for entertainment, any custom weapon system would be at least an order of magnitude more expensive. This is already the case in Ukraine btw, with FPVs being comparable in total cost to entry point Mavics, despite being MUCH cruder.

It's not a winning proposition when you take into account that those FPV launches require teams of dozens of people to support, and that good old artillery is both cheaper, scarier (=more suppressive), and more effective.

Launch 100,000 drones against what target? How do you find the target? How do you get to it without getting detected and destroyed? Where do you launch from, what's your launch platform, and is it survivable (if you just plan to bring trucks to the front line, they'll just get blown up pre launch)? How do you deal with high power directed microwave, lasers, or just basic AA shells filling the air with shrapnel for peanuts? How do you coordinate the attack, especially under EW, without saturating all bandwidth available way before you reach 100,000?

You're severely underestimating the challenges and how much it costs to solve them. There are multiple reasons why torpedo boats never worked against competent navies, despite being theoretically much cheaper than battleships or modern destroyers; many of those reasons still apply to those ideas about cheap drones.

In the end it might very much be cheaper and more effective to use a good old JASSM-ER.

Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by ribosometronome on Thursday April 18, 2024 @11:48AM (#40077444)
Going to be expensive to equip every area with anti-drone systems.
Re:USAF Test Pilot School, DARPA announce aerospace machine ... by toss1 on Thursday April 18, 2024 @02:02PM (#40078942)
The AI bot/drone returns home

It is also a lot more maneuverable and has far more flexible mission profiles