News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Facebook Fallacy - Without an earth-changing idea, it... by jerf on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @08:55AM (#4007542)
Bear in mind a bubble doesn't imply that there's no opportunity, or even that there's no revolution. The ~2000 bubble wasn't a bubble because it was wrong, the Internet has revolutionized pretty much everything that we thought it was going to, and continues to do so. It just didn't do it at quite the promised pace, and wasn't able to sustain that much investment, that quickly, nor did it necessarily take the shape that everybody at the time was convinced it would.

So when I say we seem to be in an advertising bubble, it's not a statement that there isn't a revolution in advertising coming that somebody is going to profit from, it's a statement that it isn't coming at the pace people like Facebook are promising, nor can it sustain that level of investment profitably. I did make sure to call out Google for having legitimately advanced the field. If the bubble pops they'll get hit, but I have every confidence they'll survive and thrive, because they definitely have real value, just as Amazon has survived and thrived after the last bubble.

(I expect somewhere in the 5-15 years time frame there's going to be a robotics bubble too, and it won't be because robots that can coexist with us in our houses and streets won't be every bit as revolutionary as the hype claims, it just won't be revolutionary as quickly as the investment would require.)

Re:The Facebook Fallacy - Without an earth-changing idea, it... by jonnathanson on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @10:00AM (#4013063)
"a bubble doesn't imply that there's no opportunity, or even that there's no revolution"

I don't disagree.

"So when I say we seem to be in an advertising bubble, it's not a statement that there isn't a revolution in advertising coming that somebody is going to profit from, it's a statement that it isn't coming at the pace people like Facebook are promising, nor can it sustain that level of investment profitably."

Again, I think we're in complete agreement here.

"If the bubble pops they'll get hit, but I have every confidence they'll survive and thrive, because they definitely have real value, just as Amazon has survived and thrived after the last bubble."

True, which may actually make Google a fantastically cheap buy if the ad bubble pops and they take a momentary hit. Their fundamentals are solid and aren't going away anytime soon -- unless, of course, Facebook gets its act together and cannibalizes Google's ad dollars. While I think that's distinctly possible -- and Google has been anxious about it for years -- it seems that the threat isn't as immiment as once expected. The threat still exists, however. And maybe, in a weird way, the recent fiasco with Facebook's IPO will actually buy Facebook some "air cover" for awhile -- allowing it to develop killer ad products under the radar, surprising everyone with their rollout. (I think this must be the thesis of anyone still holding onto Facebook stock right now).