Doesn't seem so to me. I always run Adblock, but after looking around a bit at some DECK-served sites (there's a list on http://decknetwork.net/), I might whitelist their ads. They seem unobtrusive and mindfully-designed.
You seem to be saying that advertising networks could never work, but don't back that up with data (which, ironically, is what you're asking unalone for).
> the occasional full page background adverts they run on IMDB
I hate those. They ruin a consistent website experience, and then piss me off when I accidentally click the giant margins. The AV Club does this also - or used to, I don't know, I blocked 'em.
You started off by saying:
> I'd like to propose an alternative.
But never did so. What's the alternative?
I actually meant alternative explanation to the parent's observation that all advertisers seemingly have suddenly all become idiots.
It's based on the premise that you can auction off people's attention to the highest bidder. And to some degree yes, that still does work, a little. In the 21st century there are better ways. The best "advertising" is not recognizable as advertising at all. It's greasing the wheels of people buying something they already want. If you look at amazon, for example, they have the recommendations system, an extensive product review system, and a referral system. All of these are there to help guide people into buying something. Amazon is best served when a customer buys something they actually want, as is google. It strengthens their brand and deepens user engagement. This is precisely what facebook needs to be doing but haven't, partly because unlike with google, any degree of advertising is intrusive on the experience of using facebook. And if they get into the cycle of just dumping more and more generic, "attention auction" ads on their users then they will have failed. People will merely ignore the ads or they will spend their time elsewhere if the site becomes too obnoxious to use.
I also think YouTube is onto something with the skippable ads. If the ad is interesting enough to catch your attention in the first 5 seconds, you watch it. Not very intrusive and an opportunity for me to watch a movie trailer and forces brands to do something super creative.
The comparison of Facebook ads (web ads in general) to newspapers competing for small local businesses is right on.
Personally I think the problem isn't people doing an awful job, it's attention. On the TV they frequently interrupt your program but you'll endure it as the content is longer than the ad. Same with Radio. In Magazines and Papers they constantly jiggle around all the content so you have to at least scan the page to see if it's an advert or an article which means they have at least a chance to grab your attention.
Web ads cannot grab your attention because the content they surround is bite-sized so any attempt to interrupt is so much more jarring. They tried a few different ways and generally they failed. The worst new one is the put an ad in the middle of the text, but that too is incredibly jarring and confusing. Another example is the attempt to monetize funny videos by putting a 15 sec ad clip in front of it. But quite often this is as long as the content! Do people even try and endure the ad? I'd love to see the numbers. If I click play on a random video and an ad starts I usually skip to the next article rather than watch the ad.
Also when you get into something like Facebook the adverts sit in the same place every time. Which you learn to skip automatically very quickly as you're usually not interested in them. You never have to play hunt the article apart from the very occasional site that has the full page popups which generally means you will start avoiding that site.
But worse for advertisers, if they make them too intrusive people can just turn them off. Brilliant!
The only ad I've recently seen that made me think, hmm, this could work are the occasional full page background adverts they run on IMDB.
Also Facebook didn't used to have ads, they just added them to the side of the page at one point. And I doubt the future of ads does look like the Deck Network, it's just another advertising network. They seem to be teaching some strange ideas at your college, I'd be interested to see the data that backs it up.