Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin...
by jcrawfordor on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:03PM
(#40054464)
If you scroll down to page 3, there is a concrete proposal. The citations for this are worth reading as they expand on the idea, e.g. https://journals.sas.ac.uk/deeslr/article/view/5240/5083
The proposal is directly informed by the Post Office scandal in that it basically requires the prosecution to produce the same already-existing documents that revealed that Horizon had significant known faults.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin...
by minimalized on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:36PM
(#40054118)
The alternative is treating systems based evidence the same as witnesses. They're examined and cross referenced because they are rightly not presumed to be reliable.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin...
by jack_riminton on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:59PM
(#40055141)
I like this idea but since software and the data that runs through it changes constantly how would a system be interrogated if an incident were several years ago and the complete data picture cannot be reproduced?
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin...
by slotrans on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @02:03PM
(#40055203)
Then the maintainers of the system have failed in their duty, the evidence cannot be verified, and it must be thrown out.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin...
by gotstad on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:26PM
(#40054746)
Well, in many safety-critical industries (e.g. manufacturing of medicinal products) you actually need to maintain objective evidence of its validation.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin...
by numpad0 on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @12:49PM
(#40054289)
I'm guessing the other possibility is requiring a third party entity, like a university professor in CS, to testify unlikeliness of computer malfunction due to cosmic rays && bugs, for each and every computer generated evidences.
If the `alleged theft amount by defendant` == (unsigned int)((int)-1), that should cover those cases, at least in theory. The profs would just blindly vouch it, but at least it'll be a point.
Re:The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operatin...
by orangesite on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @01:12PM
(#40054572)
Nope nope nope and nope. The author of the software and their source code shall be interrogated on the witness stand by one of their peers and a proof checker.
edit: gender neutral language
Extending this rule to LLM’s would clearly be disastrous. At a minimum, a record-keeping system needs to be written the old-fashioned way.