Re:Supreme Court Lets Stand Student's $675,000 Penalty For D...
by bradleyjg on Monday May 21, 2012 @04:10PM
(#4004685)
The number one factor in trying to predict whether or not the Supreme Court will grant cert (an appeal) in a given case is whether or not there is a Circuit Split on the question. The number two factor is whether or not the Solicitor General, representing the United States, suggests it grant cert.
In no circumstance should the denial of cert be considered an opinion one way or the other on the merits of the case.
The district judge reduced the judgment from $675,000 to $67,500, citing constitutional concerns analogous to those that were found for punitive damages in BMW v. Gore (1996), which put a cap on how big a multiplier punitive damages could be over actual damages (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_of_North_America,_Inc._v._G...). The Appeals Court reversed on somewhat technical grounds, arguing that common-law remittitur (a process for reducing excessive awards) should've been pursued before considering the constitutional question, under a doctrine of avoiding unnecessary constitutional questions. So on remand the District Court will be able to reduce the damages as excessive on non-Constitutional grounds, but in that case, unless Sony agrees to the reduced damages, they could ask for a new trial (whereas, if Tenenbaum had prevailed on his constitutional argument, that'd be that).
People were hoping the Supreme Court would take the case mainly as an opportunity to extend the reasoning of BMW v. Gore to statutory copyright damages, rather than only punitive product-liability damages. It's possible the Court didn't want to do so. Or, it's possible they wanted to wait for at least another Circuit Court to weigh in before looking at the question. Also, it's possible they thought this issue about whether to pursue remittitur first added an unwanted complication to the case that made it too messy to hear as a test case (the court often looks for test cases that cleanly present a Constitutional issue, free of entanglement with subsidiary questions and procedural messes).
edit: The introductory section of the Appeals Court decision, which is the one the Supreme Court declined to review here, is actually fairly readable as a summary of their holding: http://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/pdf.opinions/10-1883P-01A.pdf