No we don't. Not about the individual.
But we do know that this was the correct choice for the majority. We also know that the majority didn't take it. So we know that the majority made a mistake.
It doesn't take much of a lapse to void the benefits.
I personally chose an Amex card with better rewards, but higher interest, since I pay it off in full every month.
You, or your girlfriend, don't know what's best for a particular customer's usage pattern.