News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why good external SSDs are faster with Apple Silicon by ajross on Monday April 15, 2024 @09:37AM (#40040412)
> With TB, you know exactly what are you getting.

The article is literally detailing a Thunderbolt device that behaves differently when plugged into different macs, precisely because of the ambiguity introduced by the USB4 modes.

"You know exactly what you are getting" is a story about a specification being unambiguously written. It doesn't say anything about what happens when you have dueling specs on the same port, which is the problem here.

Re:Why good external SSDs are faster with Apple Silicon by vetinari on Monday April 15, 2024 @09:49AM (#40040532)
The article is detailing a device that has dual protocol support: TB and USB. It prefers TB in one case and USB in another. I don't see any ambiguity here: it goes down the list: USB 4, TB, USB 3.1. The Intel macs are missing USB 4.
Re:Why good external SSDs are faster with Apple Silicon by ajross on Monday April 15, 2024 @10:02AM (#40040671)
> [big list of specifics about what works where]

So, you agree that the specification landscape is a soup of incompatible variants which make practical interoperability mostly a crap shoot for consumers. You just don't think that's a problem?

Re:Why good external SSDs are faster with Apple Silicon by CharlesW on Monday April 15, 2024 @11:17AM (#40041709)
I believe he's responding to the characterization of the drive as a "Thunderbolt device". As the article and @vetinari note, the drive supports both Thunderbolt and USB. It's sort of a given that that performance would be different based on which "mode" it's in.

One related complication of sharing a physical standard is that all Thunderbolt 4 cables work for USB 4, but the reverse isn't true. Ideally that would not be the case, but people want their cheap USB cables.

Re:Why good external SSDs are faster with Apple Silicon by paulmd on Monday April 15, 2024 @12:02PM (#40042340)
> With TB, you know exactly what are you getting. On the connector, there's a flash icon (meaning: thunderbolt) and a number (if > 3). That number says, which TB version it is.

that's absolutely not true at all - for example, cables can be either active or passive, which is not denoted on the cable. Many devices will not work over a passive cable, because it does not provide power.