News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by mdasen on Sunday April 14, 2024 @01:48PM (#40032889)
This strikes at an issue we haven't really addressed enough in non-profits: how much community benefit do they need to offer?

A non-profit simply means that there are no investors who can profit from the business. However, I think we haven't really thought enough about how much community benefit they need to offer to justify being tax exempt - and it's a hard problem.

For example, let's say I run a non-profit hospital. We start getting a lot more revenue than costs. At a for-profit company, that's profits, but we don't have any investors. I decide "No, we shouldn't lower prices or forgive medical debt. I want to use that excess money to create a fancy new medical building with my name on it and to create a medical research unit that will bring prestige to the hospital (and hopefully useful medical research that will help people in the future)." Right now, that's an allowable non-profit use of that money. Universities do things like this all the time: a fancy new student center takes precedence over lower tuition.

How do we deal with this? It's hard. New buildings aren't simply unjustified costs. My city wants to build a new elementary school because the current one is crumbling. A hospital or university will likewise need to invest in its facilities, but at some point it potentially crosses a threshold from necessary and useful spending toward vanity and serving the institution more than it serves the mission. Universities spend money on research-only professors who don't teach and things like that drive up tuition costs, but is that a reasonable expense for a university? It can depend on who you ask because different people will have different opinions on the purpose of a university.

It's also hard because a successful non-profit will want to reinvest in itself and keep enough excess on hand in case something bad happens. Let's say I'm running a hospital and our costs are $1B in 2022 and we took in $1.2B. I use the excess $200M to rebate some of the fees to patients and forgive some medical debt. In 2023, our costs are again $1B and we took in $0.9B. Now I'm in a tough position. Do I lay off staff? Pay cuts? Take out a loan for $0.1B? What if 2024 is also a lean year?

Likewise, let's say that I'm trying to run a patient-friendly facility. We take people without insurance and don't make them worry about the cost. Even if I'm able to successfully run my facility, other non-profit facilities that aren't as friendly are taking in more money. They start to pay their doctors better. Their facilities are newer and better kept. Nurses complain that I'm being stingy with their contract. The other hospitals are publishing fancy papers and their doctors are giving conference talks that attract donors away from my hospital.

I think there's a survivorship thing happening here. If you have too little runway, you don't survive lean times. You run out of money and one of the less friendly hospitals "buys" your hospital (which often isn't a cash purpose since they're non-profits, but some sort of promise of keeping the mission of being a hospital alive).

Should the government bail out non-profits who are serving the community better? Maybe, but it's hard to define that. The fancy non-profit hospitals will argue that they're serving the community even better. The rich and connected probably see the fancy hospitals as better and are likely their donors. The general public probably doesn't understand that one hospital might be more forgiving than another. So the general political consensus will likely be "why should the taxpayer bail out a place that's 'poorly run' when the 'well run and better' hospital is willing to bail them out with no cost to the taxpayer?"

So, in order to keep my hospital, I can't run it too friendly. Plus, for my ego, I'd rather people think well of my hospital. I'd like to brag about the fancy new facility and have people think I'm doing something amazing. We give a lot more esteem to the president of Harvard than to the president of a school that's educating and helping way more people, but isn't as fancy.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by sarchertech on Sunday April 14, 2024 @02:38PM (#40033283)
> This strikes at an issue we haven't really addressed enough in non-profits: how much community benefit do they need to offer? A non-profit simply means that there are no investors who can profit from the business.

Non-profit and tax exempt aren’t the same thing. A non-profit must apply for tax exempt status and the IRS will look at things like public benefit vs private benefit, diversity of control etc…

A vanity hospital that is controlled by 1 person who tends to put his his name on everything, and that benefits the person running it more than the public could lose their tax exempt status.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by briffle on Sunday April 14, 2024 @03:16PM (#40033594)
My local hospital just had a bit of a freak out a year or two ago, and laid people off, and cut back on services because they had a $13m salary shortfall. They are the busiest ER on the west coast. in 2019-20 (right before covid), they pad $140M cash for a new tower building, and they still have a $1B 'rainy day fund'.
Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday April 14, 2024 @03:26PM (#40033652)
The problem is more obvious in reverse: profit is money extracted from community wealth.

It may be reinvested to create more community wealth. But until that happens it's effectively removed from the collective resource pool and monopolised by private owners for private ends.

This is not great when it's abstract numbers, but it inevitably seems to concretise as privileged individual control over property, land, exclusive status symbols such as yachts and private jets, control of media outlets, and ownership of corporations - all of which are potent destroyers of community health and community wealth.

The tail is wagging the dog. Community wealth is treated as the left-overs after privileged individuals have taken their share. It should be the other way around.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by johngladtj on Sunday April 14, 2024 @03:55PM (#40033908)
>The problem is more obvious in reverse: profit is money extracted from community wealth.

On the contrary, profit is the part of the wealth generated by the company that remains with those who generated it!

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by robocat on Sunday April 14, 2024 @04:46PM (#40034330)
Yeah: the old companies take everything argument (quite true for many organisations and departments).

Where's the other side of the ledger: the services and products that the company provided to the community.

Hospitals are a great example. Put money in, get some health out.

How do we value getting our bladder fixed?

It is easy to look at the money and forget what we get in return.

What value do we get from an iPhone? If no more smartphones were produced I wonder where the market price would shift to? We could even find out if China has a war.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by antisthenes on Monday April 15, 2024 @12:34PM (#40042762)
> On the contrary, profit is the part of the wealth generated by the company that remains with those who generated it!

Only if 100% of the profit is distributed to the workers of the company.

Also, this is not relevant for a non-profit (which may also have profits).

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by johngladtj on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @10:30AM (#40052425)
Why do you think workers should be entitled to more than they agreed contractually?

Should they also be liable for the losses incurred?

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by antisthenes on Tuesday April 16, 2024 @11:00AM (#40052846)
Your original statement was lacking important qualifiers. If you provide additional info, I'll be able to answer your questions.
Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by johngladtj on Monday April 22, 2024 @05:21PM (#40121082)
What qualifiers?
Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by gdmt on Sunday April 14, 2024 @03:29PM (#40033683)
This is a great comment. It speaks to the tensions between being ethical/doing the right thing and running a business.
Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by dragonwriter on Sunday April 14, 2024 @03:03PM (#40033491)
> This strikes at an issue we haven't really addressed enough in non-profits: how much community benefit do they need to offer?

I think you mean 501c3’s with their tax-deductible donations (i.e., wealth-favoring tax subsidy), not non-profits more generally. “Community benefit” is not even in principal a common feature of nonprofits (even tax-exempt nonprofits) as a class, but it is the notional justification for 501c3’s specifically.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by anovikov on Sunday April 14, 2024 @02:55PM (#40033422)
Start with the biggest "nonprofit": church. How much community benefit does it bring?
Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by AnthonyMouse on Sunday April 14, 2024 @02:51PM (#40033387)
> However, I think we haven't really thought enough about how much community benefit they need to offer to justify being tax exempt - and it's a hard problem.

It doesn't really seem that hard. If somebody wants to build a new building to do medical research, and the medical research benefits the public, what does it harm if they also put their name on it?

If anything it's a well-aligned incentive. They'd want the thing with their name on it to be associated with public goods like curing diseases and not disreputable things like waste and corruption.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by maxerickson on Sunday April 14, 2024 @06:54PM (#40035228)
For profit corporations should also be held to the standard that they are a net benefit to society. Otherwise, why bother?

Of course it's hard to measure that benefit.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by lotsoweiners on Sunday April 14, 2024 @10:53PM (#40036658)
> For profit corporations should also be held to the standard that they are a net benefit to society. Otherwise, why bother?

Aren’t the profits the end goal? I’d like Bezos or Musk’s money and wouldnt really care if I’m benefiting “society” one bit to get it.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by maxerickson on Sunday April 14, 2024 @10:58PM (#40036676)
Sure, I'm not talking about your attitude, I'm talking about what society should tolerate from you. If you use incorporation in a way that is harmful to society, we should dissolve your corporations.

So ideally you'd be working for your profit with an awareness that there are probably some other things that you should consider.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by mlrtime on Monday April 15, 2024 @08:04AM (#40039405)
We have this already, laws and regulation.

It may not meet your current form "harmful to society" but society mostly has this figured out already.

Re:Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes by maxerickson on Monday April 15, 2024 @09:11AM (#40040111)
Sort of. There's an awful lot of conversation that tends to ignore it, treating profit as the only thing that merits consideration.