News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EVs are lowering Bay Area's carbon footprint by gorgoiler on Saturday April 13, 2024 @12:47AM (#40020576)
I believe this is a question worth asking — and answering.

Page 13 of this report from pro-climate MIT science advocacy group The Union of Concerned Scientists is of interest: https://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/attach/2015/11/Cl...

It claims the manufacturing CO2 footprint for an EV would almost be identical to the footprint for a similar ICE vehicle except for the battery which does indeed increase the EV’s footprint by 15%.

However they also claim that the total CO2 footprint for a 135,000 mile lifespan is still just under 50% less for an EV. This is of course due to the operational CO2 cost being much less for an EV when compared with an internal combustion engine.

I don’t know how many ICE vehicles are scrapped before their time due to an EV purchase but the CO2 overhead of switching to a brand new vehicle will be recouped within a few tens of thousands of miles.

Re:EVs are lowering Bay Area's carbon footprint by merek on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:37AM (#40020773)
The lower EV total CO2 footprint is based on current grid CO2 emissions (page 13):

> We use U.S. average electricity grid emissions to estimate manufacturing emissions, while the average electricity grid emissions intensity during vehicle operation are based on a sales-weighted average of where EVs are being sold today.

If the grid is supplied by a growing proportion of renewables + lower CO2 sources over time, the lifetime CO2 footprint of EVs should decline further.

Re:EVs are lowering Bay Area's carbon footprint by gorgoiler on Saturday April 13, 2024 @04:47AM (#40021563)
EVs with an efficiency of 150Wh/km charged from a grid that only pollutes at 100g/kWh (eg Brazil, Canada) have a footprint as small as 15g/km.

The US grid is 4x dirtier than that but 60g/km still doesn’t come close to 180g-200g/km of an ICE doing 8l-9l/100km (25-30 mpg.)