* at least until there are so few players searching for matchmaking games that it never succeeds in finding a lobby, of course. see diabotical for example ;-(
From my experience it’s a bit of a logistical nightmare to organize groups and cost prohibitive to spin up servers. Yea we can typically get 5 but a full balanced 10 man is real hard.
100% agree you can’t rid of cheaters but this is the hope to just avoid them through a platform.
A modern mid-range phone is probably more powerful than any server 20 years ago and those ran 64 players.
I see frustrated reddit threads where people can't get it to work, with some confidently advising in those threads that you only need ipv4. Argh!
In my view a mix of rando’s on quick-play and community run/moderated servers with voting is the only way to keep the riff raff out. You and your buddies play your server. Rando’s can join too but you get to control them and vote for ones you play well with. The ones who get voted up enough gain some limited power to also police the riff raff.
One thing is clear - we can’t keep relying on game dev companies to spawn hosting provider approved instances without oversight.
This is not true and has not been true for years. With crossplay disabled, games on Xbox and Playstation are truly cheat free. It doesn't happen. There is no dark web marketplace selling aimhacks because it isn't possible to install them.
Keep enjoying your console lobbies… while you can.
Also, you will never have a cheat less video game. There will always be a way. And if you don’t think there is, then they can continue their current iteration in perpetuity.
It’s too easy for someone to pull out their credit card and buy a cheat than it is to catch them.
I don’t play FPS games anymore because every lobby is full of them. Tracking behaviors and putting them into their own tier of matchmaking is one way. Detecting modifications of memory and banning is another. The issue is that most game devs are using an engine and the engines themselves are vulnerable.
Private servers, self-hosted servers, are the way. You get admin control and you decide who you want to play with.