Most people (say, 999999 out of every 1000000) will consider a rock unintelligent and Stephen hawking to be intelligent. You can't call them wrong because "they cannot define intelligence".
> If we just started simulating neurons in a brain exactly, what would prevent us from achieving inorganic intelligence in your view?
Nothing. But the word "If" is doing all the heavy lifting in that argument. I mean, we aren't doing that at the moment, are we? It's not clear that we might ever discover exactly how the collection of neurons we call a brain "exactly works".
IOW, if the human brain was simpler, we'd be too simple to understand it: this may already be the case!
And the evidence for "we may not figure out how the brain works exactly enough to clone the mechanism it uses" is a lot larger than "we might figure out how the brain works well enough to clone the mechanism it uses."
This is why I remain unconvinced. Even though I think your position is a reasonable one to hold, the opposite position is, IMHO, just as reasonable. It's got nothing to do with religion or superstition.
Can you give me a clear, minimal definition for both "intelligence" and "instinct"?
Because to me, instinct seems to be already achieved by existing inanimate control systems for decades now, and "decent understanding of natural human language" (as achieved by todays LLMs) is more than enough to count as intelligent for me.
If we just started simulating neurons in a brain exactly, what would prevent us from achieving inorganic intelligence in your view?