News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by fleitz on Sunday May 20, 2012 @04:48PM (#4000044)
The patent in this case is simply getting the blame for a failed launch, as an excuse to collect insurance. This is like blaming a smoke detector patent on a building being burned to the ground to collect insurance. "We couldn't afford smoke detectors because they're patented, and we're in a lawsuit with a manufacturer"

It has nothing to do with the patent and everything to do with collecting insurance.

Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by oh_sigh on Sunday May 20, 2012 @08:27PM (#4000693)
That is absolutely not the case, and I don't see how you could make that conclusion.

To draw an analogy, imagine your car runs out of gas near the top of a mountain. You put on the e-brake, and assess your situation. The nearest gas station is 20 miles away, and it's snowing, so there is no way you can walk it, and there is no other traffic on the road to offer you some help. Sucks to be you, but you should have planned better. You could let go of the e-brake, and roll down the mountain in reverse, but there is just a deserted valley at the bottom - it would not improve your situation. But, a ha! You realize that you are only 20' from the top of the hill. the gas station is still 20 miles away, but it's all down hill. If you can push your car to the top of the hill, you can then roll all the way to the gas station using gravity to power your car.

But, alas, a lawyer pops out of the woods, and hands you a document stating that you are not allowed to push your car up the hill and then use gravitational potential energy to get to the gas station, because Acme, Inc has been issued a patent on that process, and you are not allowed to use it without their consent. Coincidentally, you have an ongoing lawsuit against Acme, Inc, for a completely unrelated reason. They tell you "Drop this lawsuit, and we'll let you use our push-up-the-hill process to save your car".

That is pretty much what happened in this circumstance.

Yes, the engine failed to operate properly. No one is blaming the patents for that. The satellite got stuck in an unusable orbit due to the engine failure, but was otherwise still functional. Since launching things into orbit is very expensive, and the things being launched are very expensive, the company that owns the satellite will try pretty much anything within reason to recoup their costs. One option, popularized by Belbruno and Ridenoure from an similar incident in the past, involves using only a small amount of fuel, to send the satellite around the moon and back, which would make it possible to put the satellite into the correct orbit around the earth. THIS is what was denied them due to the patent on the low energy orbital transfer that Boeing apparently has. So, it is not the fault of the patent system that the rocket initially failed, but it is the fault of the patent system that the company was not legally allowed to recover it's still-functional property.

edit: I should add that, yes, SES Americom may have committed insurance fraud if they didn't disclose to their insurance company that the satellite was recoverable for $50M(the cost of dropping the lawsuit against Boeing). However, that doesn't change the fact that they were prevented from essentially running their engine at particular times due to patents.

Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by DugFin on Monday May 21, 2012 @11:03AM (#4003147)
> I should add that, yes, SES Americom may have committed insurance fraud if they didn't disclose to their insurance company that the satellite was recoverable for $50M(the cost of dropping the lawsuit against Boeing)

I'm pretty sure that insurance companies can't consider the estimated cost of a civil suit as a fungible asset like that. They could no more insist that SES comply if Boeing had asked them to kill Boeing's mother in exchange for a trajectory license. After all, it costs less than $50M to kill someone.

Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by oh_sigh on Monday May 21, 2012 @03:15PM (#4004392)
I agree. I am not at all certain how insurance contracts work, so I didn't want to speculate, but I also didn't want to leave out that possibly-relevant piece of information. Most likely, instead of offering a license in return for dropping the lawsuit, Boeing could just offer a license at the cost of what they expected to lose in the lawsuit(which is still around $50M). In that manner, the satellite would have been recoverable without any connection to the lawsuit.
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by pavel_lishin on Monday May 21, 2012 @12:17PM (#4003519)
Can you make an analogy that doesn't involve a felony crime?
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by freshhawk on Sunday May 20, 2012 @06:15PM (#4000286)
The fact that trajectories are being patented at all is what I took away from this. That's astounding in it's ridiculousness. I assumed that was why this was posted.

Your analogy makes no sense, the failed launch has nothing to do with the patent, the patent just stopped an attempt at saving the satellite. So more like the factory caught on fire and no firetrucks could come because a competing factory had patented the route from the firehouse.

Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by onosendai on Sunday May 20, 2012 @06:58PM (#4000401)
Agreed, this whole patent nonsense has officially crossed over into dystopian sci-fi territory.

Steve laid down his MacPad Pro next to the water cooler and hailed Tom over. "Guess what, I took the A9 this morning, I don't know why I don't do it more often, no traffic, no headaches, pure bliss." Tom eyed him with a frown, waiting a couple of seconds before replying. "The A9? You have a family Steve, aren't you worried about them?" "What do you mean?" "Don't you know that entire route is patented? What happens if your plates' RFID tag comes up in a random check and they find out you haven't licensed it? The lawsuit would drag you under for sure."

Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by dpkendal on Monday May 21, 2012 @10:21PM (#4005980)
Isn't this usually called a toll road?
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by glimmung on Tuesday May 22, 2012 @02:17PM (#4009079)
nope - this would be a troll road...
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by Retric on Monday May 21, 2012 @01:17AM (#4001397)
Trajectories can be both useful and non obvious so I can see the patent angle. Think of it like this someone had to come up with this orbit 30 years after we started putting satellites in geosynchronous orbit's or the patent would have expired. And they only get to keep the patent for 20 years so any of the early 'gold rush' patents should have expired.
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by fijal on Monday May 21, 2012 @07:11AM (#4002264)
Patents are also required not to be discoveries. I claim the orbit existed long before the Boeing company was funded.
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by Retric on Monday May 21, 2012 @08:09AM (#4002450)
Unlike say genetic patents noting natural can make these maneuvers as they require one or more fuel burns to make the transitions from orbit A to orbit B.
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by ajuc on Monday May 21, 2012 @10:34AM (#4003009)
So, can I patent route that ship takes through the ocean? Or air corridor?
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by Retric on Monday May 21, 2012 @01:49PM (#4003962)
There is prior art for most useful and static trade routes.

However, you could probably patent a system that uses real time satellite imagery to discover the location and magnitude of ocean currents, predict what they will be for the next week, and then calculate the the ideal routes for a fleet of cargo ships in real time. But, the patent is only going to last 20 years and shipping companies would probably just wait you out. Then again, I expect that patent probably exists and expired a long time ago.

Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by ajuc on Monday May 21, 2012 @03:05PM (#4004334)
Yeah, but assume I've patented the system for calculating etc, etc the route, and the patent had not expired yet.

If somebody else used the same equations I've used, but made the calculation on his abakus, and steered his ship by himself, he wouldn't infringe my patent, I think.

Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by gaius on Monday May 21, 2012 @06:44AM (#4002191)
That's astounding in it's ridiculousness

Indeed, which is why it's not what happened. Repeat after me: you cannot patent an idea, only a mechanism for implementing an idea.

Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by regularfry on Monday May 21, 2012 @09:44AM (#4002768)
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by roc on Monday May 21, 2012 @10:54AM (#4003107)
Except for business method patents.
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by freshhawk on Monday May 21, 2012 @06:14PM (#4005192)
I'll repeat it as much as you want, will that make business method patents go away?

The patent in question is for the idea of "moving a satellite" using the mechanism of a certain class of trajectories.

So how is this not what happened?

Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by AJ007 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @06:24PM (#4000298)
A better analogy would be, your child was killed by a motorist who couldn't stop quickly enough because the car manufacturer was unable to license patented anti-lock braking technology. (hypothetically assuming anti-lock braking technology was not mandatory by safety standards and was one of several safer stopping methods.)
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by mkmkmmmmm on Sunday May 20, 2012 @11:33PM (#4001135)
That would not be a better analogy because you are shoehorning in an emotional component as well.
Re:Satellite killed by trajectory patent by Ralith on Monday May 21, 2012 @04:49AM (#4001942)
I assure you, people get quite emotional about large sums of money.