Re:ActivityPub/Nostr/At-Bluesky Compared
by grumbel on Sunday April 07, 2024 @02:57PM
(#39962876)
With ActivityPub you are still putting everything in one basket. All the federation is completely optional and identities are not transferable. But unlike big corps, that generally care very little about what you do, a whole lot of ActivityPub instances are heavily politically motivated and love to block or defederate.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:ActivityPub/Nostr/At-Bluesky Compared
by BadBadJellyBean on Sunday April 07, 2024 @05:57PM
(#39964324)
That's not entirely correct. Mastodon already implements a feature to migrate to a new instance. Also there is a draft for identities that are not bound to an instance.
what do you mean by draft? Is this something actively worked on
Re:ActivityPub/Nostr/At-Bluesky Compared
by malermeister on Monday April 08, 2024 @04:01AM
(#39967308)
You can't even post titties on Facebook/Insta. Big corps are intensely politically motivated, they succumb to American prudery through advertiser pressure.
Even the more centrist tend to block instances. Especially because the others are politically motivated. Who in the center of the political spectrum would want to federate with gab for example? The same goes for the other extreme, like some instances which are full of tankies. When you federate with them you can't have a single news topic without getting "NATO evil, Putin great" pile-ons. It derails every discussion.
One of the nicer centrist instances is Beehaw and they defederated a lot of stuff just to keep the atmosphere alright.
I used to think it was a bad thing when instances defederated each other but since I saw the above happening I agree with it.