Re:I found that the company I work for is putting backdoor i...
by wpietri on Saturday May 19, 2012 @11:41AM
(#3996173)
That's not being sneaky at all; it's in the commit logs and he can announce it. It's just shifting the burden of action back to the people who want the vulnerability. In theory, the same. Practically, very different.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:I found that the company I work for is putting backdoor i...
by eli on Saturday May 19, 2012 @02:12PM
(#3996570)
It's obviously not just a regular commit and everyone involved would know that. The commit log is not a proper place for a thinly veiled ethics complaint.
If you think something is wrong, have the courage to say so directly, don't hide behind a commit message.
Re:I found that the company I work for is putting backdoor i...
by wpietri on Saturday May 19, 2012 @05:21PM
(#3997103)
As both employee and employer, it's my view that all employees should what they see as the right thing by default.
Personally, I think the poster should make the change and then announce it. I'm not saying he should be cowardly. If anything, I think the cowardly choice is to futz around trying to get consensus an elusive around doing the responsible thing.
Re:I found that the company I work for is putting backdoor i...
by Mz on Saturday May 19, 2012 @03:16PM
(#3996744)
Since they claim they won't use it and he says it was probably a mistake, this sounds to me like exactly the correct response: Let them save face and "agree" with the change if they are so inclined. A high handed accusation of an ethics issue does not look supportable at this time. And it is likely the worst thing he could do.