Re:We Who Value Simplicity Have Built Incomprehensible Machines
by luser001 on Saturday May 19, 2012 @11:52AM
(#3996208)
"I think his point is not that "ls" needs less flags, it's that it needs no flags."
Then don't use the flags. The default bare 'ls <wildcard>' is sane 99% of the time for me, and I consider myself a junior power user.
Re:We Who Value Simplicity Have Built Incomprehensible Machines
by adavies42 on Monday May 21, 2012 @02:57PM
(#4004293)
same here. in fact i'd call it a power law--90% `ls`, 9% `ls -l`, .9% `ls -ltr`, .09% `ls -lhSr`, .009% `ls -d` .0009% `ls -i`, etc.
which suggests the default behavior, and arrangement of the flags, is very well designed.
(if i could change one thing, it'd be to make all the sorts ascending by default....)
I think his point is not that "ls" needs less flags, it's that it needs no flags.
Or that libpng is low-level versus high-level, it's more that there shouldn't even be a concept of low-level.
And the other thing he seems to be saying is that backward compatibility should be abandoned to allow libraries to actually mature instead of just bloat.
It was certainly food for thought to me. And you even seem to agree in the paragraph of Let me tell you what it's like to design small and simple software...