Student loans are normally fixed interest rate loans and they only charge penalty's when your late in paying them.
The problem with increasing rates when people get into trouble is it tends to force more people over the cliff. Let's say you owe 20k at 10% and make 50k/year. You get hospitalized for 5k and your old and new rate becomes 33%. You have gone from a 2k /year to 5k/year when you need to borrow 5k more. If the company lending you 5k wants to charge you 33% interest that's fine you can focus on paying them back first and get free of debt but when everyone starts raising your rates while your in trouble it's almost impossible to get out of the hole.
PS: Not to mention demonstrating a lack of good credit is an ill defined concept. Loss of a job reduces credit worthiness even if you make all your payments.
That's not true.
Many commercial bond and loans include covenants that cause changes (loan gets called, interest rate changes, etc) when certain things (sales revenue, money in bank, etc) happen.
Some even tie their interest rate to external factors, like LIBOR.
And, biz credit lines do get pulled.
> Loss of a job reduces credit worthiness even if you make all your payments.
It's unclear if you find that wrong or not. Job loss may well affect future ability to repay even if you're current now.
Private student loans are variable interest rate loans, many at the whim of the providing company. (I'd agree that private student loans are much closer to evil than revolving credit, and that more education is due on both topics to consumers of both types of debt. But I'm still not in favor of restricting the availability of a financial product that might not be in any given consumer's best interest, so long as it is in the best interest of some consumer.) Govt-backed student loans are as you describe.
As to the over the edge "problem", that's a problem of the consumer's making+, and a creditor acting in their own best interest probably OUGHT to tighten credit for borrowers that it identifies, even on an acturial basis using information unrelated to the direct consumer<->creditor interaction, as being a higher risk.
+ - Debtors who are not in over their head generally don't face these problems.
Edit: Ok, running the numbers it would not be that bad but I would become far more focused on having zero debt.
Not that the last 3 months suggests the idea is without risk but it's not enough money that I really care. However, if I had less in the way of assets an my rate where to spike I would quickly start caring.
Same reason as the Mortgage Industry. The credit card issuers have been irresponsible to the point that the entire system is in danger of failing. They have lent so much money to so many people who can't afford to pay it back that it appears likely that there is going to be a huge cost to society, including those who have behaved responsibly.
In other words, we do not only have to protect consumers from their inherent irrationality. We have to protect society from the inherent irrationality of the financial industry as well. If this is not true, please explain to me how we would not be better off right now if there were regulations in place that could have prevented financial companies from taking on the amount of risk that resulted in the vaporization of Wall Street.
Why shouldn't a lender be a able to offer a contract that allows them to increase their fees when the borrower shows themselves to be a less than ideal credit risk at some point in the future? The borrower signed the terms; if they didn't like them, they could have not signed them, or they can pay off and close the account now. Those are the two (non-bankruptcy) avenues for them to get out of the contract that they now don't like having signed.