I don't mind the discussion on it the past couple days, god knows wherever I get information from isn't the one blessed source, but I am worried about HN's instinctual "from first principles" reactions to undersea mining. Made me wince a little bit when I saw the post you're replying to say "I am always surprised when I find others don't just assume that undersea mining is more impactful."
I really appreciated you gently pointing out there's other smart humans on this and they likely have considered things like the environment.
So then we're going to gently pluck them off the ocean floor, without disturbing anything else?
Or would it be more of a "grind up everything and spit out the lumps" job? :-\
Be honest, now...
It's worth investigating, in any case. I'm not advocating for taking action before getting the results of such study, though! It is important to be careful.
The only crushing argument that I would admit at this point is: "industrial fishing should not exist in the first place".
To me this fact feels like a given considering that is such a complex operation and the sea is such a delicate environment.
Of course its great to have data to back up what we know... but I'm always surprised that we have to go so far out of our way to back up what should be intuitive.