I understand both perspectives. The premise should be questioned, a correct amount. "Do not question our premise" is a weird take.
I'm not objecting to "the problem with the safe C subsets...."
I'm objecting to the disdainful "why would you do it in C?"
You didn't ask him to clarify, you asked him to leave.
Would you go into a thread about emacs and say, "Why would anyone use emacs over vi?" And if not, what makes you think you should do that here?