News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by loumf on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:16PM (#3993692)
On the one hand, this indicates that the underwriters did a good job of maximizing FB private shareholder value on the IPO.

On the other, the shape of the daily curve looks like it was supported at that level artificially.

Even if not, it doesn't look like there's a lot of market confidence for it at this level.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by gojomo on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:25PM (#3993727)
More evidence of artificial support, a tweet and screen capture from Paul Kedrosky:

http://lockerz.com/s/209964861

It's easy to overlook the graphic; it's the thin black bar with faint text. It shows:

  Bid (size): 38.00 (x9999900)     Ask (size): 38.01 (x146300)
...and the tweet referencing it was about 20mins before the close. The earlier tweet was:

@pkedrosky: Watching certain underwriters try to keep certain IPOs above their issue price reminds me of playing Missile Commander, at scale.

Still, this isn't necessarily a negative for Facebook. They optimized their take, and Zuckerberg won't be needing the market's approval or capital again for a while.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by EternalFury on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:32PM (#3993771)
It used to be "the sky is the limit". Now it is "the floor is the limit and the floor is $38". The Facebook baby bird broke out of its egg today. Next week, it must learn to fly out of the nest on its own. That should be a dinner and a show.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by asmithmd1 on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:54PM (#3993901)
Why isn't this illegal stock price manipulation?
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by stryker on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:07PM (#3993988)
It's the only manipulative practice allowed by the SEC because of the need to "maintain a fair and orderly market". This article describes it fairly well in its abstract: http://economics.ouls.ox.ac.uk/10713/1/IPOstabilization.pdf.

"Stabilization is the bidding for and purchase of securities by an underwriter immediately after an offering for the purpose of preventing or retarding a fall in price. Stabilization is price manipulation, but regulators allow it within strict limits - notably that stabilization may not occur above the offer price. For legislators and market authorities, a false market is a price worth paying for an orderly market."

EDIT: Just included the full description.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by dkulchenko on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:48PM (#3993862)
Pardon my ignorance, but what do the quoted numbers mean?
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by joering2 on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:59PM (#3993938)
It means that underwriters were putting lots of stocks to buy at the exact $38 level so that this will scare people away from selling (oh wow such a huge position someone wants to buy [$38 x 9999900 shares == $379,996,200], there is no chance someone will buy that much of a shares [and therefore stock will plunge deeper], so I better stick to my own shares and not sell).

They build rather fake barricade.

edit: depends how the big fish will play, you may see none of these Monday morning. Its probably just a hand of underwriters keeping 80% of that shares. If they withdraw, you may see only 25000 shares at $38, for example [so it will be much easier for the stock to go deeper].

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by encoderer on Friday May 18, 2012 @06:58PM (#3994470)
You're right on what it means, but not why.

This is the reason IPOs work the way they do, with investment banks underwriting it. They get a large profit (potentially huge profit) in exchange for providing the services of a market-maker in the stock at $38/share.

There was nothing nefarious, just market making.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by joering2 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @12:02AM (#3997900)
I see what you are saying, but don't you agree: hadn't not demand got burned out quickly and drew the price down, they wouldn't have had to put a large buy order at $38.

I mean, do you really believe they were offering $300MM of stock ready to sell on an "open action". They would all shit their pants if someone would have actually execute that.

No, what they did was not illegal, But yes, what they did was unethical and anyone knowing anything about trading will take it as a negative sign in terms of this stock's performance.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by tazzy531 on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:28PM (#3993745)
What's going to be interesting is how long they can hold this support.

Banks can't take on too much risk on their books.. especially in the post Dodd-Franks world.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by Klinky on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:23PM (#3994087)
Didn't JPMorgan Chase just lose $3 billion? Seems like they're still a little too good at taking on risk.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by davvid on Friday May 18, 2012 @07:14PM (#3994523)
The $3B is only what's been reported. Tip of the iceberg.

FB is being propped up to lure in "retail" investors. Retail investors == "muppets" == dumb money. If FB stock is so great then Goldman would be holding onto it themselves. Are they doing that? No. They are selling. $38 is their exit point. Anyone who's buying in will be left holding the bag. That is the whole point.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by encoderer on Friday May 18, 2012 @07:00PM (#3994474)
And it's important to remember that $3bn is a fraction of one quarters profit at JPMorgan Chase.

A lot of people could thusly call that perfectly acceptable risk.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by Klinky on Friday May 18, 2012 @07:33PM (#3994580)
One half of quarterly profits is a pretty big fraction.

Exec resignations & the CEO apologizing doesn't sound like a lot of people are very accepting of the risks taken.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by encoderer on Friday May 18, 2012 @08:17PM (#3994695)
Days after the story broke shareholders had an opportunity to replace Dimon as the chairman and reducing his comp package -- leaving him with the CEO title. They overwhelming voted not to.

It's a big fraction, but it's just one quarters profits. It's not the destabalizing, company-breaking amount of money some people make it out to be.

JPMorgan has over a trillion dollars in assets on its books. The chicken-little nature of this has been a little silly I think.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by Klinky on Friday May 18, 2012 @09:17PM (#3994817)
Most shareholders had cast their ballot way before the loss was reported.

JPMorgan is not out of the woods, they have to unwind their positions to an unfriendly market. This ordeal may also make them more risk adverse, but possibly less profitable in the short-term. Less profits, more losses, isn't going to make people very happy.

I don't think it's the end of JPMorgan, but acting like they have $3 - $5 billion in the couch cushions doesn't sound very rational either.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by 3am on Friday May 18, 2012 @07:42PM (#3994620)
http://finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=JPM - it's more than half of an entire quarter of profit for JPMorgan Chase, actually. Everything I've read says the $3B will increase as they try to exit the position, too.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by loverobots on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:40PM (#3993816)
Still, this isn't necessarily a negative for Facebook. They optimized their take, and Zuckerberg won't be needing the market's approval or capital again for a while.

Technically, but the minute you go public you have to worry about the stock price. If the stock drops (IMO, it will drop here) expect a deluge of doom and gloom stories from the media questioning their business model and everything else in between. Then you may have unhappy employes due to the stock drop, harder time hiring, higher expenses since the stock price isn't rising and so on. Bezos did it so far, but it isn't easy. Zuckenberg sold a nice chunk of his $100 Billion company, buyers will be vocal if the price drops.

FB will have to do everything right for a few years just to justify the $100 billion price tag. It's not easy as ads can drive people away.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by joering2 on Sunday May 20, 2012 @12:04AM (#3997903)
good read, I +1 you. And don't forget that Facebook does not have a special place in media when it comes ONLY to a positive news; they will write about them big time whether its good or bad news. This will definitely not play nice when there are some bad news, because lots of publicity around bed news will have an impact on their stock performance.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by state_machine on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:28PM (#3993751)
This is the greenshoe option at work:

When the price is determined, the shares are ready to publicly trade. The underwriter has to ensure that these shares do not trade below the offering price.

If the underwriter finds there is a possibility of the shares trading below the offering price, they can exercise the greenshoe option.

http://www.investopedia.com/articles/optioninvestor/08/green...

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by gdubs on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:33PM (#3994148)
Ugh. What is it about finance that I find so hard to grok... So, essentially they're able to offer more shares than they originally agreed to, correct? Where do those extra shares come from, and how exactly does that help keep the price above water?
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by AndyIngram on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:56PM (#3993914)
No its not. Over allotments are to stabilize the lack of sellers above the offering price and to raise additional capital for the issuer. It could be a reason for the price returning to $38 but most likely that was not why either. The buys at $38 can be explained by other factors like orders from people or funds who did not get all or any of their requested allotments and had resting orders at 38. Overall the markets are skittish and the price range is high based on current earnings but there is so much potential future earnings, I think we will see much higher prices if not right away some time in 2013.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by squeee on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:57PM (#3993927)
So... get short on FB?
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by AndyIngram on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:14PM (#3994032)
That's your choice.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by uptown on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:23PM (#3993717)
It was unquestionably held up by underwriters ... unlikely to continue into next week.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by mratzloff on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:51PM (#3993881)
> On the other, the shape of the daily curve looks like it was supported at that level artificially.

Facebook's too big to fail!

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by cookiecaper on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:32PM (#3994142)
The prospect of that reality is frightening. Facebook is so large now that if it went away the amount of civil discontent would be a point of concern for politicians (primarily if Facebook's disappearance gets pinned on them).
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by shangrila on Friday May 18, 2012 @07:13PM (#3994521)
The flipside of that of course is that they can pass whatever draconian regulations they want in regards to the internet, so long as Facebook gets a free pass and is allowed to keep chugging along. Surprised they didn't do that already for things like SOPA.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by cookiecaper on Saturday May 19, 2012 @02:16AM (#3995231)
Facebook would in practice get a free pass on things like SOPA. AFAIK SOPA left discretion up to whatever agency would have been charged with enforcement (likely ICE or SS), so reports asking for the removal of Facebook would, of course, never be allowed, but reports on any/all of FB's competitors would go through.

That is one of the reasons lobbying is such an important game for conglomerates. Once you're on top, regulation is your friend; it's much cheaper to hire paper-pushers to fill out forms and submit them to the feds than it is to actively respond to and dismantle competitors. If only MySpace had gotten something like this in place a little sooner, FB would have been destroyed and MS would still be on top.

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by joshz on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:01PM (#3993950)
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by hiddenstage on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:35PM (#3993795)
It beat the market. Not saying it will over the short/long term, but it went up on a day the majority of the market went down.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by Cyndre on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:17PM (#3994052)
Where do you think the billions used to buy facebook stock came from?
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by earl on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:21PM (#3993701)
here's the pricing chart for today [1]. What makes you think it was supported -- the flat line beginning at 334 pm?

[1] http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=FB+Interactive#symbol=fb;...;

Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by maayank on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:25PM (#3993726)
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by nextparadigms on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:01PM (#3993946)
I watched it go to down to 38.00, and then went up again 0.01, 0.02, etc, slowly. I don't think it dropped at all under 38.00, and it was most likely manipulated.
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by loumf on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:23PM (#3993714)
Yes, that and the rally at almost exactly that level a little before 12pm
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by kami8845 on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:45PM (#3993848)
There's also similar things going on around 40. Any chance they tried to hold the round 10?
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by sks on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:25PM (#3993730)
Well the price did come very close to $38 several times (twice before 12:00 and then during the flat part at 3:34 that you mentioned) but the price never crossed below $38. This does show a lot of resistance/support at $38
Re:Facebook closes at $38.23 first day NASDAQ trading, above... by encoderer on Friday May 18, 2012 @07:10PM (#3994512)
Yes, of course, because the underwriters in an IPO act as market-makers at the IPO share price. That's their function in exchange for making an obscene profit taking a company public.