News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by InclinedPlane on Friday May 18, 2012 @12:34PM (#3992715)
I'll add my voice to the chorus of folks gushing about how awesome this is, but here's a list of reason on just WHY this is so awesome.

Straight off the top, this is only the third launch of the Falcon 9. This rocket alone represents a dramatic disruption of the entire orbital launch industry, offering to make launch of both humans and cargo cheaper than it's ever been by an incredibly wide margin. If this rocket proves to be a reliable workhorse and proves that the existing cost structure is workable then it will both dramatically lower the cost of access to space and drive billions of dollars of revenue to SpaceX.

Second, this represents a significant advance in being able to deliver supplies to ISS, largely replacing a vehicle that is vastly more expensive than the Dragon Cargo. And finally putting American spaceflight back in the game of ISS resupply post-Shuttle.

Third, the Dragon Cargo shares an enormous amount of heritage with the manned Dragon capsule in development. As they prove out elements of the vehicle design in unmanned ISS resupply missions they are effectively proving out the manned version as well. The manned Dragon capsule will represent a huge leap for the US space program, catapulting us back into having the capability to send crew into orbit and to the ISS.

Fourth, given the costs of Falcon/Dragon flights they should be enormously disruptive to manned spaceflight, representing a vastly cheaper way to put humans in orbit even than the Russian Soyuz. That will likely translate into far more people beingable to go into orbit and the development of a sustained orbital tourism industry on an impressive scale which will fuel further innovation and drive down cost of access to space even more.

Finally, all of this is being done by a private company working toward its own ends rather than a company on a strict government contract. This represents a new paradigm for launch vehicles and for manned spaceflight, potentially transforming the nature of the entire endeavor into something that is self-sustaining regardless of government enthusiasm for spaceflight.

In short, this represents nothing less than fundamentally rebooting the entire space program going all the way back to Sputnik, and it could quite readily represent the opening up of spaceflight for commercial applications, space science and exploration, and for manned exploration and colonization to a degree that will make the scifi dreamers of our past look like forecasters.

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by joshuahedlund on Friday May 18, 2012 @12:55PM (#3992834)
Can you give some numbers for some of the "vast" cost difference we're talking about (even if they're ballpark figures)?
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by InclinedPlane on Friday May 18, 2012 @03:12PM (#3993409)
First, let's take the Shuttle off the table, which is no longer in service and was by far the most expensive launch vehicle in extensive service in history.

Right now, the price of a Falcon 9 launch is around $50mil, this translates to $4.8/g to LEO or $16.7/g to GTO (which is where most satellites go). This compares very favorably to the price of other western launchers (Atlas V: $18/g, Ariane 5: $21/g, Delta IV: $19.5/g to GTO and around $11-$14/g to LEO) and is very competitive compared to Russian launchers (Soyuz 2: $16.7/g, Proton M: $18.2/g to GTO or $6.4/g and $4.8/g to LEO respectively).

However, keep in mind that these are prices, which include a healthy profit margin for SpaceX, and it's no coincidence that they have priced themselves right at the level of the otherwise cheapest launch vehicles in the world (since that maximizes their profit margin). Also keep in mind that as SpaceX's operations and manufacturing become more streamlined, as they amortize the fixed development costs for the Falcon 9 (which won't take long since the costs are a small multiple of the per flight revenue), as flight rate increases, and as competitive pressure to lower their profit margin increases they will be able to offer launches for considerably less than they are today, at lower prices than the Soyuz or Proton, for example.

However, this is just the beginning, as SpaceX has several development efforts in progress. The Falcon Heavy, for example, represents an incremental evolution of the Falcon 9 design, using 3 1st stage cores (instead of just one) and using a new cross-feed system to improve performance. The thing about the Falcon Heavy is that it uses slightly less than 3x as much hardware at about 2x the cost of a Falcon 9 launch but it will be able to deliver 5x the payload. This will translate into prices around $6.6/g to GTO and $2.4/g to LEO, at the high end ($4.2/g and $1.5/g at the low end). Nobody else in the world can come close to those numbers.

Also, they are working on a fully reusable version of the Falcon 9 which will reduce costs by at least a factor of 5 conservatively and perhaps as much as a factor of 100.

The maiden flight for the Falcon Heavy is slated to be next year. And they have already begun development on the core systems for the reusable Falcon (here's the 1st stage landing gear they've built for one of the test vehicles: http://s3.amazonaws.com/imgly_production/4311966/large.jpg).

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by ebiester on Friday May 18, 2012 @03:24PM (#3993454)
Are we sure about this healthy profit? Is it possible they're just using this to try and beta their vehicle at lower cost?
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by InclinedPlane on Friday May 18, 2012 @03:54PM (#3993571)
Rather certain. Several folks have looked into SpaceX's cost structure and come to that conclusion, including NASA. They haven't paid off the development cost yet but they do run an incremental profit on each launch.
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by grinich on Friday May 18, 2012 @04:43PM (#3993843)
There's no freemium model when you're building rocket ships.
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by ebiester on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:51PM (#3994216)
Think dumping, not freemium.
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by rbanffy on Friday May 18, 2012 @06:50PM (#3994429)
Dumping requires lots of money. Dumping on the backyard of large defense contractors is suicidal.
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by davidcuddeback on Friday May 18, 2012 @10:20PM (#3994921)
I think the maiden flight of the Falcon Heavy is slated for this year: http://www.spacearchive.info/vafbsked.htm

With the way launches tend to slip, I wouldn't be surprised if you're right about it happening next year, but as of right now, it's on Vandenberg's launch schedule for 2012.

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by rst on Saturday May 19, 2012 @12:36PM (#3996324)
Latest from SpaceX management, in a press event last week: they're building it this year, but expect to launch sometime in 2013.

http://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?PHPSESSID=b4bab31...

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by rbanffy on Friday May 18, 2012 @06:51PM (#3994438)
> as competitive pressure to lower their profit margin increases

Assuming current incumbents are capable of doing that. That's a big if. If their competition can't effectively compete, their profit margins will remain steady allowing them to develop more interesting vehicles/capabilities.

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by InclinedPlane on Friday May 18, 2012 @08:42PM (#3994747)
True enough. Even so, it's in their best interests long term to price themselves a decent amount below the cheapest competition (but not too much below) to make sure they're maintaining a high enough marketshare to maximize their total profit, not just per unit profits.

Also, to some degree as the space tourism market gains traction there will be some amount of competitive pressure on the costs of orbital tourism from the sub-orbital market (Virgin Galactic and others). More so, once SpaceX has proven their business model it will drive a lot of investment capital to their competitors (both old and new) to try to level the playing field.

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by ChuckMcM on Friday May 18, 2012 @01:33PM (#3993001)
It it difficult to 'cost out' the current Soyuz infrastructure because so much of it can be accounted to zero with basic accounting. (The cost of design and development was paid off over 15 years of launches according to an old press release but that was also at a time when the then Soviets had even less of an independent press than they do today)

For me however, this in itself is a pretty amazing thing, because SpaceX is a 'company' rather than a 'nation-state' the cost accounting is actually grounded in an independent currency and without hidden funding sources (like much of both the US and Soviet space programs benefited hugely from the investment in inter-continental ballistic missile technology which was 'defense' spending rather than 'space' spending. Such games are not possible at SpaceX.

So it would be accurate to say that the Falcon9 launch system is the first system for which we know the true cost of the system. And that is pretty amazing to my way of thinking.

When you combine that with a fixed price to get various tonnage in LEO or a into a Geo/Lunar transfer orbit, you can make statements like "Getting this into orbit costs $X" with overruns/delays/randomness priced out.

With some newer work being developed for on orbit vehicles, things like Lunar exploitation and Lagrange point stations become an exercise in money rather than politics and money. And that is also a huge shift.

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by Arjuna on Friday May 18, 2012 @01:19PM (#3992936)
"Can you give some numbers for some of the "vast" cost difference we're talking about (even if they're ballpark figures)?"

"Q. How much does it cost to launch a Space Shuttle? A. The average cost to launch a Space Shuttle is about $450 million per mission." [1]

[1] http://www.nasa.gov/centers/kennedy/about/information/shuttl...

"The average price of a full-up NASA Dragon cargo mission to the International Space Station is $133 million including inflation, or roughly $115m in today's dollars, and we have a firm, fixed price contract with NASA for 12 missions. This price includes the costs of the Falcon 9 launch, the Dragon spacecraft, all operations, maintenance and overhead, and all of the work required to integrate with the Space Station. If there are cost overruns, SpaceX will cover the difference. (This concept may be foreign to some traditional government space contractors that seem to believe that cost overruns should be the responsibility of the taxpayer.)

The total company expenditures since being founded in 2002 through the 2010 fiscal year were less than $800 million, which includes all the development costs for the Falcon 1, Falcon 9 and Dragon. Included in this $800 million are the costs of building launch sites at Vandenberg, Cape Canaveral and Kwajalein, as well as the corporate manufacturing facility that can support up to 12 Falcon 9 and Dragon missions per year. This total also includes the cost of five flights of Falcon 1, two flights of Falcon 9, and one up and back flight of Dragon." [2]

[2] http://www.spacex.com/usa.php

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by eupharis on Friday May 18, 2012 @01:37PM (#3993018)
Cost per kilo to Low Earth Orbit (LEO):

  Space Shuttle: $19, 824 per kg [1]

  Soyuz-2: $5,333 per kg [2]

  Falcon 9: $5,167 per kg [3]
At the moment, the Falcon 9 is not that much cheaper than the Soyuz.

Elon Musk's talk of $1,100 per kg lies in the future. SpaceX is hoping that making all the parts reusable and its new Falcon Heavy (Which will carry five times as much as the Falcon 9) will cause launch costs to plummet like a stone.

Which is not to say SpaceX isn't amazing. It has been launching rockets for that past 6 years. Whereas Soyuz has been the 40 year work of a superpower. Achieving parity is a wonder in and of itself.

[1] $450 million cost per launch / 22,700 kg payload

http://www.nasa.gov/centers/kennedy/about/information/shuttl...

[2] $40 million / 7,500 kg payload

http://myblog.rsynnott.com/2010/03/rocket-fuel-not-as-expens...

[3] $54 million / 10,450 kg payload

http://www.spacex.com/falcon9.php

Edit: Grammar, formatting

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by tadfisher on Friday May 18, 2012 @06:27PM (#3994348)
Not cost per kilo, price. These numbers aren't comparable as-is, you have to look at the cost structure.
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by eupharis on Friday May 18, 2012 @06:51PM (#3994432)
This is cost in terms of "how much will it cost me to hire SpaceX or the Soyuz to take my tourist self / science experiment / mining robot to LEO." If you want to call that price, go for it.

Obviously this is pure theorycraft for the Space Shuttle. But if anyone has a better number please share!

$/kg is the crucial number that has to fall to bring about a new era in space exploration.

Except for SpaceX, space launch companies don't publish their prices straight up on the website. But about $5,000 per kg ballpark figure for Soyuz seems widely to be accepted by credible sources on the internet and books. See:

http://books.google.com/books?id=kN9Szy-fJVIC&pg=PA69...

If someone has harder numbers for the Soyuz, please share!

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by InclinedPlane on Friday May 18, 2012 @08:36PM (#3994727)
"Obviously this is pure theorycraft for the Space Shuttle. But if anyone has a better number please share!"

A moot point now, since the Shuttle isn't operational. However, when it was running the incremental cost to NASA was around $500 mil per launch, so roughly $20,500 per kg to LEO. Tallying the full cost per Shuttle launch (i.e. the cost to the tax payers over the full history of the program) runs to about $1.5 billion per launch, so adjust those numbers above up by a factor of 3.

Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by ANH on Friday May 18, 2012 @02:28PM (#3993238)
In the press conference about an hour ago, I think I heard Gwynne Shotwell (President, SpaceX) say Russia offers a seat for $63M, whereas SpaceX will be offering NASA Dragon launches in the $30M range. A Dragon holds seven astronauts.
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by tsotha on Friday May 18, 2012 @11:22PM (#3995008)
The Russians were offering seats in the $30M range as well until the shuttle was retired. There was a lot of anger over the adjustment.
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by ramidarigaz on Friday May 18, 2012 @01:17PM (#3992926)
SpaceX lists launch prices on their website. The prices for the Falcon 9 are a little ways down on this page: http://www.spacex.com/falcon9.php
Re:SpaceX headed to the ISS tomorrow by ChuckMcM on Saturday May 19, 2012 @02:04AM (#3995214)
And once we get one of ULA's long duration cryogenic vehicles [1] in orbit the game changes tremendously.

An in-orbit depot system for fuel would open up the moon pretty effectively.

[1] http://www.ulalaunch.com/site/docs/publications/Integrated%2...