There are so few Jews remaining in Israel/Palestine who are not hard-right and worse, that they have effectively zero influence in their government. Many who could, have already emigrated. Since many of the European Jews maintained dual US/European - Israeli citizenship, they were able to leave, if their politics did not align with the current fascist genocidal religious-extremist current. But, the remaining population is even further right as a result.
On a personal note, I have never visited a more racist ugly place than Israel. Every Palestinian I met was warm and kind (I did not hear a single negative word about Israelis or Jews, even in Palestinian refugee camps [both inside Palestine and in Jordan]). Except for two, of the many Jewish Israelis I interacted with, none could have a short conversation without peppering it with nasty racist remarks about "Arabs" (or, in one case comments, "[about how great some guy was because] he killed lots of Arabs". Jewish only roads, are a thing. Jewish settlers constantly harass and threaten Palestinians (rape and murder by Jewish settlers of Palestinians is ignored by the authorities). A society so consumed with hatred of another people simply because they exist is reminiscent of European Christian societies' hatred of Jews into the 20th century. A little irony that Israel exists because Europe's ultimate solution to their "Jew problem" was to support Zionism[3]. And, a further irony that now, Zionist Jews are using the Nazi's solution of genocide for the European "Jew problem" to deal with the Israeli "Palestinian problem".
[1] Mizrahi are second class citizens in Israel, "Jews at Arab wages" [per one left-of-hard-right Israeli Jew who grew up on a Kibbutz but emigrated from Israel to the US to escape, "the fascist turn in Israel"]. Mizrahi tend religiously conservative, but they are also voting in their economic interests too. Mizrahi are over-represented in the illegal settlements, as they are poorer on average than the European Jews, and many cannot afford homes anywhere else-- the Fascist parties support illegal settlement building/military protection of the settlements. Except for a _tiny_ number already in Palestine, the vast majority of Mizrahi arrived to Palestine/Israel after the European Jews had begun their colonialist project (including the violent ethnic cleansing of the indigenous Palestinian population to make way for Jewish settlers). And, those who were there prior were not part of the Zionist settler colonialist project.
[2] It is only with US and European support that Israel can continue with its atrocities (hell, it is only due the US and Europe that Israel _exists_). It is the non-Jewish-supremacist non-Zionist Ashkenazi in Europe and the US who are the the most important voices against Israeli genocide of Palestinians, against Israeli apartheid, against continuing Israeli land theft and home destruction, against kidnapping+indefinite detention without trial for thousands of Palestinians, including _many_ children, against the rape and torture of these Palestinian captives, and against the continued US/European support of Israel no matter how heinous their crimes. The Zionists call these Jews, like the members of Jewish Voice for Peace, "antisemitic" and "terrorists". But, calling a Jew "antisemitic" does not work as well as screaming "antisemitism!" every time a non-Jew is critical of the _many_ Israeli racist policies and atrocities.
[3] Most Jews, at the time, did not support Zionism and immigrated to the US instead.
A lot of ugly stuff is certainly said by right-wing Israelis (who are, generally speaking, more likely to be indigenous than the left-leaning Ashkenazim). But there's also a great deal of erasure of hostile Palestinian advocacy in your summary as well.
These discussions would be simpler if we could keep focus on the actual misdeeds of the Netanyahu administration, and stop trying to generalize problems out to Israel as a whole. It's not that it's impossible to make such an argument, but as you can see from your comment, those arguments are treacherously difficult to construct reliably without leaving gross, obvious, and sometimes even overtly racist generalizations in them. If you want to condemn the entirety of Israeli society, you aren't putting enough effort into your comments to do so here.
At the end of the day, I don't think it's worth it to try to litigate that kind of question. We're not going to resolve Israel vs. Palestine in an HN thread. But if you must try, the guidelines ask you to try harder than that.
Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.
All but a tiny population of pre-existing Jews in historic Palestine are settler colonialists living in territory violently ethnically cleansed of the indigenous Palestinian population to make way for Jewish settlers.
If Israel is ever forced to abide by international humanitarian law, or through boycott divestment and sanctions, Israel is forced to become an actual democracy where Palestinians are treated as human, first class citizens-- either will lead to Palestinians being able to exercise their UN mandated right of return. With the changing demographics many Ashkenazi will likely leave voluntarily back to Europe/US-- many not only have another place they call home, they retain dual citizenship.
There will likely be a turbulent period with terrorist attacks by Jewish extremists. Palestinians who lost their families to Jewish violence may also engage in revenge attacks. There may also be terrorist attacks by (American/European) Christian Zionists in a last ditch attempt to start the war in the region, that they dream of. But, under Muslim Ottoman rule, people of all religions in Palestine, including Jews, lived mostly peacefully together, so it is possible that they can again. We also have the S. African example-- many of the white European settler colonialist Afrikaners remained citizens of a free S. Africa, but they no longer rule / oppress the indigenous population.
> stop trying to generalize problems out to Israel as a whole.
95% of Israeli Jews support the current genocidal massacre of Gaza. This _is_ Israeli Jews as. a. whole. Another poll showed 80% of Israeli Jews didn't think the genocidal bombing was enough, they wanted greater destruction i.e., greater death-toll.
https://www.vox.com/2014/7/31/5955077/israeli-support-for-th...
You seem to think history of the atrocities by the settler colonialist Jews of Israel began with Netanyahu. The Jewish Zionist atrocities began prior to the founding of Israel. There has never been a period in Israel's history when they did not engage in atrocities against the indigenous population.
Netanyahu is a monstrous man, but if he were to be replaced today, his replacement would likely be just as bad, or worse. Israel is a sick society overtaken by blood lust (similar [but worse] to the US after 9/11 blow-back for US atrocities in the middle east [including support for Israel and their atrocities]).
I was unable to locate the study, but a professor of Middle East Studies (in an interview) mentioned a study conducted in Israel which found that those (Ashkenazi Jews) who experienced the Nazi concentration/death camps were more likely to be more aggressive and ruthless toward Palestinians than other Israelis.
Interestingly, Israeli society was also crueler to Jews who experienced Nazi concentration camps. These people were looked down upon as weak. No idea if this dynamic factored into the cruelty these concentration camp survivors exhibited toward the Palestinians.
We disagree, but Israeli polls, Israeli social media posts, Israeli leadership's public statements, and most importantly, Israeli actions, support my statements. Israeli Jewish society, as a whole (including Kibbutzniks living in a kibbutz on stolen land), is responsible for ethnic cleansing, apartheid, and genocide, with extra responsibility to Ahskenazi without whom there would be no Zionist settler colonial project of Israel on Palestinian land.
> erasure of hostile Palestinian advocacy
An occupied, oppressed people, even if they were not experiencing a genocide at the hands of their oppressors have a right to defend themselves both morally, and under international law.
> overtly racist generalizations
I'm sorry that you perceive things that way. It is not my intent. I've been bending over backward to attempt to separate the genocidal monsters in Israel and their supporters, from Jews in general-- non-Jewish supremacist non-Zionist Jews are some of the strongest voices against Israeli atrocities and least likely to be forcibly silenced (but, I recall, in the US, every Muslim [I am not one] being forced to declare how evil the 9/11 attackers were, and I want to see the same with American Jews calling out the genocidal apartheid regime of Israel [or, at least, admit that they too are genocidal racist monsters]). I am also not willing to pretend that Zionism isn't a European creation. Nor that the genocidal monsters in Israel are not Zionist Jews-- recent settlers on stolen Palestinian land. The latter is important, as it is, in one sentence, what the entire "middle east conflict" is about.
I would speak just as vehemently about the German Christian Nazis committing genocide against Romani and Jews of Europe. I just don't think Israeli Jews should get a pass on genocide and other crimes against humanity, just because someone else committed similar atrocities against the ancestors of some of them. And, it infuriates me that within discourse in the US and W. Europe, it is considered "antisemitic" or "racist" to criticize a murderous, racist, apartheid, genocidal, settler colonialist regime just because the oppressors and perpetrators of violence are Jewish. Imagine if criticism of Nazi Germany was instantly shut down by people claiming racism against Christians.
> Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.
You mainly have simply repeated yourself in your comment. (I am guilty of this to some extent too [necessarily so, otherwise is to concede that Israel has a right to ethnically cleanse, engage in genocide, etc., which I vehemently do not believe], but I hope you will see some of my comment as substantive content as well)
This isn't just false, it's luridly, categorically false. A plurality of Jewish Israeli citizens are of MENA origin --- from Morocco, Yemen, Iraq, Ethiopia, and other countries in the region. They're the "Mizrahim", they're a huge chunk of the population, Israel is literally their only homeland, and they tend to be more right-wing than the "settler-colonialist" Ashkenazim, who tend towards the left.
So, you agree with me. These are Jewish settlers from OUTSIDE Palestine. These followed after the initial European Jews had already engaged in violent ethnic cleansing.
When the English directed their colonialism against Ireland, the settlers were "from the region", but still settler colonialists.
This is what happened to the Palestinian _survivors_ of the original Nakba (violent ethnic cleansing of Palestine to make way for Jewish settlers):
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f7/Palestin...
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/5/56/Ol...
Zionist Jews poisoned wells, planted bombs/threw grenades into bus stops and shopping centers, mortared Palestinian villages, etc. to mass kill Palestinian civilians and "encourage" them to flee.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1948_Palestinian_expulsion_and...
What Israel is doing is putting Jews, Zionist or not, in danger everywhere, as many see the people of "The Jewish State" as committing genocide, and the Zionists are doing their best to conflate Zionism and Israel with all Jews (criticism of Israel is "antisemitic").
Outside the US and parts of the EU (especially Germany) news outlets are actually reporting on the genocide-- In the US, CNN even sends all their Israel stories, to Israel to be censored to ensure the "proper" narrative on the Israeli genocide and other atrocities i.e., Americans never hear about them.
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2024/feb/04/cnn-staff-pro-...
E.g., did you see images of the row of Palestinians lined up, face down, on the ground, hands zip-tied behind their backs, then run over by a truck, crushing them-- on your US news broadcasts (or German)? Someone, anywhere in the rest of the world might have. The Israelis are committing monstrous acts for most of the world to see, while claiming that they represent all Jews.
I'm curious, why do you defend them? "Never again" should mean Never again for anyone.
This is a long-dead thread and we need not keep it alive.
Agreed.
You haven't outright admitted it, but your technique of repeatedly accusing those criticizing Israeli policies/atrocities as being racist while never addressing any of the Israeli atrocities is SOP for Zionists.
Good luck. Hopefully some day, you will consider the lives of the indigenous Palestinians of equal value to those of the brutal genocidal Israeli Jewish Zionist settler colonialists who stole the Palestinians homes, land, and the lives of their children, parents, brothers and sisters-- people who never had a quarrel with Jews before the Zionist Jews, of Europe, attacked them, and stole-- everything.
The ratio you cite is terrible even if you accept Israel's extremely dishonest framing.
More children were murdered by Israel in the first months of their "10,000 eyes for an eye"[1] massacre of Palestinians than in the entire Ukraine war.
The Israelis held a rave with bouncy house blocking a roadway to prevent aid convoys from getting through. And, of course, to celebrate the young children and babies starving to death by their actions.
Small Israeli schoolchildren sing songs of killing all the Palestinian children while video of Israeli bombs tearing apart Gazan children's bodies plays in the background (posted to social media by proud Israeli parents).
Israeli soldiers sing songs of killing all the Palestinian children while they kill Palestinian children (posted to social media by proud Israeli soldiers, and entered into evidence in the Israeli genocide hearing at the UN).
More journalists (and their families) murdered by Israel, in so short a time, than any other war.
More UN aid workers murdered by Israel than any other conflict. A current UN observer called it "unprecedented". A former observer resigned in protest of the inaction to stop the genocidal massacre of civilians by Israel.
Babies in incubators left to starve to death after forcing the medical workers from the hospitals, and in one case, their many tiny bodies left to decompose for weeks, in the incubators. Israeli Zionist European settler Jews do not consider the Indigenous Palestinians whose homes and land they are stealing as being human (cockroaches, rats, human animals are all terms Israeli leaders have used to describe the massacred Palestinians).
Israel is targeting civilians, those that provide assistance, and those reporting on the horrors inflicted upon the Palestinian civilians.
Israeli soldiers have a history of targeting civilians (especially children). In their Operation Cast Lead, the Israeli snipers wore t-shirts with a pregnant woman in a rifle cross hairs with the caption in Hebrew below, "One bullet, two kills."
A few years ago, there was unarmed march to the wall that encloses what has become the concentration camp / death camp of Gaza-- Israelis murdered 300 unarmed protesters (46 children), and maimed over 36,000 (8,800 children). The Israeli snipers aimed for the protesters' knees to permanently maim them.
Being an apologist for genocide, and the monsters committing the genocide, is inexcusable.
[1] The Israelis call this latest genocidal operation, "10,000 eyes for an eye".