News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by mschuster91 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @06:08PM (#39923877)
> You could also technically use this as a grid-battery, taking in excess grid energy when it is cheap and converting it into natural gas that can be run back through a gas peaking plant that spins up to meet peak demand.

The loss in such a cycle is abysmal, alone from thermal loss (not to mention the loss during compression and decompression) - even straight fuel cells are at 60% round-trip, compared to batteries with >>90% efficiency.

Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by pydry on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @07:11PM (#39924527)
Batteries are good at smoothing out daily or even weekly variations but do not make any sense whatsoever for seasonal power storage.

It's ridiculously cost ineffective to charge a battery in July only to discharge it in December.

60% roundtrip is cost effective if you're synthesizing when the sun is blazing and the wind is blowing hard and burning it when wind, solar and batteries have all tapped out.

Thats especially so if the equipment has low capex which it seems like this does. Unlike batteries that makes it cost effective to overbuild and idle it most of the year.

Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by cbsmith on Thursday April 04, 2024 @02:14AM (#39927096)
Is that more effective than the traditional, "store the energy as kinetic potential energy by pushing water uphill, so you can let it go down the hill later" approach.
Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by pydry on Thursday April 04, 2024 @04:13AM (#39927743)
For storing energy cheaply for months at a time, yes.

Pumped storage has similar characteristics to batteries - 90% roundtrip efficiency, good at storing energy for days or weeks but maxes out easily. Economically you can think of it as a lithium battery that is 1/2-1/3 of the price but takes 5-10 years to build.

Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by danmaz74 on Thursday April 04, 2024 @05:37AM (#39928285)
It's not more effective where you have the right conditions for pumped storage, but those conditions aren't very common around the world.
Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by pydry on Thursday April 04, 2024 @05:46AM (#39928325)
I'm curious about where you read this. I see this idea that pumped storage geography is rare pop up a lot on Hacker News but I don't know where it's coming from and it rarely seems to come with citations.

If you look at this map, you'll see that unlike, say, dam-appropriate geography, it's actually extremely common:

https://www.energytransitionpartnership.org/uploads/2023/05/...

Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by danmaz74 on Thursday April 04, 2024 @06:58AM (#39928741)
I'll admit that I wasn't talking about potential green-field sites not linked to rivers or existing reservoirs, as described in your link. How many of the sites they identified as viable with their algorithm would actually be economically, socially and environmentally viable is a big question though. Not saying some of these sites can come to fruition, but for sure the capex and lead time for this kind of projects is huge.
Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by pydry on Thursday April 04, 2024 @08:06AM (#39929316)
I guess that answers my question. People are getting pumped storage and river dams mixed up. It seems mschuster91 also mixed them up.

Yes, the capex and lead times on one of these things can be huge, but it's comes out ahead of nuclear power on those fronts.

Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by mschuster91 on Thursday April 04, 2024 @08:14AM (#39929411)
> People are getting pumped storage and river dams mixed up. It seems mschuster91 also mixed them up.

The environmental impact is bad for both.

River dams break fish crossings, the dammed up area gets flooded and wipes out nature as well as archeological artifacts and the dams are at constant risk of damage - especially in a war, see Ukraine for multiple examples, but also due to maintenance neglect, negligence during construction and natural disasters like earthquakes. In the worst cases such as China's Three Gorges dam, millions of people were displaced as well [1].

Pumped storage can come in two variants, either as an associate to ordinary river dams (so they inherit their issues), or as greenfield construction, where they have the same impact on the flooded are, with the additional impact of countless animals dying during pump and empty cycles.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Gorges_Dam#Displacement_...

Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by pydry on Thursday April 04, 2024 @11:59AM (#39932105)
A link to the three gorges dam wikipedia page says exactly nothing about the potential environmental impact of pumped storage but it does confirm that you are confusing the two technologies.
Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by mschuster91 on Thursday April 04, 2024 @01:37PM (#39933545)
... which is why I linked to the Three Gorges Dam in the paragraph where I described the issues with dammed storage, and made an entirely separate paragraph describing the issues of pumped storage.
Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by pydry on Friday April 05, 2024 @05:20AM (#39940387)
Thats exactly my point. You assumed they share the same environmental characteristics i.e. you're confusing them.

They do not: https://www.energy.gov/eere/water/articles/lower-environment...

(this is the second citation to a relevant scientific study in this thread. the first one was also mine)

This is getting to seem a bit like those screeds I see about wind farms killing all the birds from nuclear, oil and gas people who see it as a threat.

Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by mschuster91 on Thursday April 04, 2024 @06:11AM (#39928479)
The problem is, the potential for buildouts of pumped hydro isn't that large any more. In Europe, most usable areas have been built out, and new projects are likely to be denied because anything involving creating dams or bodies of water with rapid differences in water level is incredibly devastating on nature and wildlife.
Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by cbsmith on Monday April 08, 2024 @02:42PM (#39972554)
More or less devastating than extracting heavy metals and setting up a battery farm?
Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by genman on Thursday April 04, 2024 @05:58AM (#39928391)
Figure 2 doesn't agree with you. It's common but not geographically equally distributed.
Re:Terraform makes carbon neutral natural gas by ben_w on Thursday April 04, 2024 @05:47AM (#39928334)
> It's ridiculously cost ineffective to charge a battery in July only to discharge it in December

Indeed.

This is why the cheapest solutions in most places are a mix of a mere few days off storage plus a target production level that is a little higher than you need on an average day in winter.

While this doesn't work above the arctic circle (you could do it with a power line somewhere sunnier or a synthetic fuel, and possibly also geothermal or nuclear etc., devil is in the details for all options) overproduction + 35-90 hours of batteries is sufficient for most people and places:

https://tonyseba.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/RethinkingEn...