News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by jonahbenton on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:08PM (#39923165)
Policy rather than technical issue. US has first amendment, other regimes do not. What will the moderation policies on that instance be? How nazi or porn does someone's post need to be to be "censored" where in this case it is actual censorship since it is a govt managed instance. What degree of promotion by govt constitutes propaganda? How much energy would be wasted litigating these arguments. Just completely infeasible from policy standpoint for a US govt entity to operate a public publishing platform.

[edit] And yes, a Presidential candidate owning / operating / profiting from / accepting laundry and bribes on / such a platform is- should be- completely unacceptable.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by rglullis on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:23PM (#39923355)
I mean running a service only for officials. They don't have to accept any type of content that they wouldn't accept in their own published websites, and they would moderate the content just like it was an account hosted on the existing platforms. Why would it be any different?

> What degree of promotion by govt constitutes propaganda?

How does that differ from any information that is distributed through Facebook/Threads/Instagram?

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by jonahbenton on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:58PM (#39923790)
> Why would it be any different

Sure, running a Mastodon that didn't accept non govt users and on which there was no engagement with the public- no different than a website, and as the technology is in every respect less mature, scalable, secure, etc than web platforms, no reason to do it.

> How is it different...

It is tied into the "censorship" issue and who else is allowed to publish. Think about any actual "state" controlled press- China and Russia are famous examples. The only publishable statements are those that align with goals. And there is no user engagement.

Imagine a govt platform with engagement, publishing a controversial statement leading to a large response. There will have to be moderation. How well do those moderation policies align with or conflict with information propagation goals?

A commercially mediated platform has its own incentives and its own business to run, to act in ways that balance concerns. And sometimes it may decide not to permit govt officials to spew what amounts to propaganda. Such a decision would never occur on a govt operated platform, of course.

==

Relatedly, the main subtext from Biden's announcement of course is that Twitter is no longer a viable "official" publishing/engagement platform. Look for many, many other govt bodies to arrive at similar determination.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by rglullis on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @06:41PM (#39924233)
> didn't accept non govt users and on which there was no engagement with the public

That's not what I said. You can have a server where only govt officials have accounts, and other people could respond to it.

> There will have to be moderation.

Yes, so?

> Such a decision would never occur on a govt operated platform, of course.

Why couldn't it be structured in a way similar to how PBS operates?

> Twitter is no longer a viable "official" publishing/engagement platform

Your quotes are doing a lot of work there. Yeah, communication via Twitter or Facebook was was never considered official. And it shouldn't be. And honestly, it shouldn't even change if it was happening from their own servers, because while the medium can be useful to get people closer to the "debate", in reality the real action and "official" communication warrants a lot more formality and weight than any microblogging platform provides.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by jonahbenton on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @07:23PM (#39924651)
With respect, "Yes, so?" to the moderation problem is like standing next to Everest and saying "Yes, so?" It's far and away the single biggest concern.

Policy is everything. Lots of engineers don't understand this, as engineers we concern ourselves mostly with the "mechanism" side of the "mechanism vs policy" duality. We think about doing things, moving forward, confronting problems as we go. In reality, we live in a bubble. The real issues are policy domain. Policy is mostly about what not to do.

Non-corrupt government operating a platform requiring moderation involves so, so many "do not do that, you lose" nodes on the decision tree as we presently understand it that there is no winning strategy. The only way to win is to not play that game. Don't get into the business of moderation if you are a non-corrupt government.

> Why couldn't it be structured in a way similar to how PBS operates?

Well, for a few reasons. The main one is that government in general and the US government in particular is extremely powerful. That power attracts attention. Everyone with an interest impacted by the government- which is everyone- needs to attend to that power. The President "favoring" a platform will attract many many parties to that platform, who wish to carry influence or have an impact. Many of these parties have their own immense powers, both technical and policy/informational.

PBS is in literal terms a TINY operator. $700M in revenues last year. A staff of a couple thousand people. As an organization it doesn't have any of the capabilities to operate a real time two way communication platform requiring it to act as a real time moderator against the myriad actions that a China or Russia not to mention countless other actors could throw against it. Of course, many would argue neither does Facebook. But with 100,000 staff and hundred billion+ revenue- it has more of a chance.

Could such an organization be stood up? The policy questions again are- who funds it, to what end? What problem would it solve? There are no good reasons for a govt to spend the $Bs it would require and no good solutions to the first amendment problems it would create.

I appreciate that there is a notion of the "public interest" that one would think everyone agrees on, which is what one imagines governments should be about. There can be a sufficiently common shared understanding of "public interest" in small communities, even scaling to homogeneous states (say, single digit millions of citizens). But "public interest" breaks down pretty quickly with sufficient community heterogeneity.

> Yeah, communication via Twitter or Facebook was was never considered official.

Well, in fact, it was. Prior to Musk, many government agencies had "official" voices/presence on twitter. And much work went into- from a policy perspective- ensuring what was communicated was suitable. Occasionally policy was "made" or announced first on twitter. You will now see those presences increasingly quiet (or loud) quit, due precisely to Musk's failure at the moderation problem.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by rglullis on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @07:49PM (#39924836)
My "yes, so?" is not that dismissing the issue, it is actually just looking at Twitter (and also Facebook) and thinking "how come using those platforms with numerous issues are not a 'policy problem?"

Twitter was hacked, the POTUS account was used to promote crypto scam, and this is not a "policy" issue?

Threads is owned by a company who has repeatedly involved in scandals about how data is handled, how is that not a "policy" issue?

I honestly don't buy this argument. If the government position was that nothing on social media should be "official" and this is why any presence gets less oversight, okay. If the position is that the presence is official as long as the participants adhere to govt guidelines, okay. But those same guidelines could be applied on a public-owned platform.

What I don't get is that they can claim that their presence is official while on the private platforms but are somehow unable to act in the same way if the platform was public.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by jonahbenton on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @08:35PM (#39925144)
> how come using those platforms with numerous issues are not a 'policy problem?

Yes, it is, in a way- there is an implicit endorsement. That has to be balanced with the opportunity to craft messages directly to the audience the potentially problematic platform serves. But use does not entail responsibility.

FB/Twitter were/are policy problems, but their operation is not the responsibility of any specific actor in government. The issue is more diffuse.

> Twitter was hacked, the POTUS account was used to promote crypto scam, and this is not a "policy" issue?

Yes, it was a problem for Twitter, because they were the operator. The statements made under the POTUS account were not actually made by POTUS. So not really a policy problem for POTUS.

> Threads is owned by a company who has repeatedly involved in scandals about how data is handled, how is that not a "policy" issue?

Sure, but the government is not the operator. It is not responsible for Meta's failings.

> I honestly don't buy this argument. If the government position was that nothing on social media should be "official" and this is why any presence gets less oversight, okay. If the position is that the presence is official as long as the participants adhere to govt guidelines, okay. But those same guidelines could be applied on a public-owned platform.

Neither of those is the rule.

When a designated government voice speaks, that's "official", no matter what medium through which that speech occurs.

There may be problems with the medium, and the government authorities responsible for regulating those problems will take those issues up with the medium. They are responsible for regulating, not responsible for operating. The government entity using the medium will often continue to do so, even when there is a seeming conflict.

One sees this all the time in the financial sphere, where there are many regulators and many service providers which in theory need to be in compliance with the requirements of the various regulators but every day there are questions and disputes and claims and counter-claims and so forth. It happens all the time that one government agency is making use of a service provider for something while another government agency is suing that same service provider.

> What I don't get is that they can claim that their presence is official while on the private platforms but are somehow unable to act in the same way if the platform was public.

Yeah- it's completely different, if by "public" you mean "substantially controlled or operated by a government entity." Because then government is both accountable and responsible. When it's a private operator, the operator is responsible, and government at best is just accountable, if something really bad happens.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by rglullis on Thursday April 04, 2024 @11:49AM (#39931943)
I'll be honest: all of this seems just a rationalization to avoid the initiative and to give power needlessly to corporations.

Multiple European Governments have set up Mastodon instances, none of them have required millions of dollars or hundreds of people on payroll. None of social media services are essential to official, institutional communications.

It does not need to be that complicated.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by bartonfink on Thursday April 04, 2024 @02:08PM (#39933935)
Downvoting this pabulum isn't enough.

You're right, in an abstract HN bullshit sense. It does not need to be this complicated. Nevertheless it is, for reasons that are much more complicated than setting up a Mastodon instance. You are obtusely ignoring the complications.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by rglullis on Thursday April 04, 2024 @05:26PM (#39935975)
So the answer is just "American Exceptionalism"?
Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by bartonfink on Friday April 05, 2024 @01:41AM (#39939011)
If America is exceptional in specific relevant ways, yes. No points for you, go back to history class.
Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by krapp on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:18PM (#39923296)
Also people would complain that their tax money is being wasted on pointless government infrastructure when Twitter, Facebook, etc. are right there, and free.
Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by rglullis on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:29PM (#39923425)
The cost to run and operate a social media server is negligible in comparison with the payroll for people managing POTUS account on all the different platforms.

Also, "people" complain about everything, it doesn't stop the government from spending however they want.

When there is a will, there is a way. If these are the best "reasons" to not do it, seems like it is just a lack of will to be independent from Big Tech.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by krapp on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:57PM (#39923766)
The people are already there, the infrastructure is already there, and the cost is already being borne by someone else.

You could describe that as "a lack of will to be independent from Big Tech" if you want, but the fact remains there is no rational reason for the government to run and maintain its own social media infrastructure when it doesn't need to, and when almost no one would bother to care if they did.

Re:Ask HN: Why can't the US government run their own social ... by rsynnott on Thursday April 04, 2024 @06:59AM (#39928747)
Nothing stopping them running something along the lines of https://social.network.europa.eu/ (the EC's mastodon instance); as only government bodies have accounts, it's not doing moderation for the general public.

> Just completely infeasible from policy standpoint for a US govt entity to operate a public publishing platform.

Poor Voice of America :(