I don't think he'll need to get to Mars to be on that list.
Lastingly transforming the economics, reusability, and safety of rocket and vehicle technology in his short lifetime will be enough.
Musk and Spacex are already on track to benefit humanity 500 years from now and beyond.
And that's just one of his companies. Let's not forget PayPal and Tesla, which, while not as important to the future of humanity, both represent successful leaps forward in technology and economics.
I was actually thinking the other day about the people alive today who might be household names in 500 years - if Elon Musk achieves his goals for reaching Mars then his is probably the only name on that list.