Re:Timeline of the xz open source attack
by klabb3 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:43AM
(#39915280)
> to spot this kind of thing in any Turing-complete language
I’m not sure I follow. The bar for passing review and audits is “people can understand it”, at least to the point of preventing smuggling in a custom public keys and other shenanigans – as opposed to “all valid programs in the language”. While I agree Turing-completeness opens up undeniable complexity, it’s the best we got. And there are huge variations in obscurity across languages and tooling.
Re:Timeline of the xz open source attack
by khaki54 on Thursday April 04, 2024 @08:21AM
(#39929487)
Underhanded C is meant to create code that is transparent enough to convince the reader that it's obviously and clearly doing one thing, while subtly doing something else.
I’m not sure I follow. The bar for passing review and audits is “people can understand it”, at least to the point of preventing smuggling in a custom public keys and other shenanigans – as opposed to “all valid programs in the language”. While I agree Turing-completeness opens up undeniable complexity, it’s the best we got. And there are huge variations in obscurity across languages and tooling.