The mention to other "malware" is spurious. This was a highly engineered/targeted attack. Mentioning "malware" just sounds plausible because your brain files the word in the same region as "RCE".
Running `strace` shows `/usr/bin/uname` just calls `uname()`, which just reads out some string literals in the kernel. It is unlikely to be randomized accidentally.
And deliberately signalling the presence of other hacks by making the `uname` syscall non-deterministic would be highly inefficient (Return 8 strings just for one bit of data?), highly unreliable (Check how many times to be sure?), highly visible (Human-readable, and human-targeted.), and unnecessarily difficult (Kernel-level hack?).
…And now you see how much effort it takes, to even start to examine/debunk an implausible and unfounded idea that cost you seconds to prompt and OpenAI fractions of pennies to generate, which took root and seemed "plausible" and "enticing" specifically because GPT was trained in an adversarial way to exploit how us humans can fall for bullshit if it's packaged in the right way…
---
1: The word for that is "Lying". ChatGPT is a Lying Machine. Sometimes the lies line up with parts of reality, but that's more luck than intent. And it's usually still lying even in those cases, just in smaller, subtler, or less blatant ways.
I’m not going to submit a paper to a scientific journal treating the information as a fact but this is a public discussion forum on the Internet, so I’m happy to speculate in the open using the hallucinations of an algorithm if they seem interesting.
I'm not calling LLMs lying machines just because they sometimes hallucinate and get things wrong. I'm calling them Lying Machines because they literally don't have either the hardware or progeny to be able to care about any concept of the truth, whether regarding explicit simple physical facts or about the intentions of a reciprocal conversation. They are, literally, designed, trained, and selected to fool humans so Sam Altman (and many others) can get his bag.
You seem to have an axe to grind, good for you, I think we need lots of variety of opinion and passion as a society.
That's the opposite of having "lots of variety of opinion and passion as a society". It's outsourcing cognition to a machine designed to emulate the most banal, superficial, and mediocre aspects of human expression.
You continue to grind your axe without considering or responding to my opinion about LLMs utility as a tool. Like any tool, it can be used for good and bad things.
No matter what you feel about LLMs and other generative “AI,” they’re here to stay. If you choose to be ignorant of how to use such tools to your benefit, nobody is going to stop you.
Evidently not.
> codezero 1 day ago
> [flagged]
Do you always get this upset, argumentative, and perceive personal attack when people disagree with you?
The comment I responded to literally said:
> My only hypothesis is that the attacker may have thought that it should look plausible as a test
The entire premise of this thread is speculation, which I did. Furthermore, the GPT response prompted me to come up with my own speculation (I won't call it a hypothesis, as this is not science):
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39917474
I never said anything about a personal attack. You didn't disagree with me (There wasn't anything to agree to, I was speculating), you went on a tirade about how much you dislike people using ChatGPT. I don't have a problem with you, or your opinions about ChatGPT, in fact, I respect them.
You also haven't considered one thing: Posting trash responses by various LLMs on public forms will help weaken future LLMs by poisoning their inputs. If you hate LLMs so much, you should consider doing your part to poison their inputs so they become irrelevant, case in point, this thread is the third result for "uname used in malware" on Kagi, and first on Google. Stop being a passive participant and fight LLMs at the front if you care so much.