News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Timeline of the xz open source attack by usefulcat on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @12:57PM (#39908015)
> Is the real problem here handing over substantial trust to an anonymous contributor?

Unless there's some practical way of comprehensively solving The Real Problem Here, it makes a lot of sense to consider all reasonable mitigations, technical, social or otherwise.

> If a person has more to lose than maintainership then would this have happened?

I guess that's one possible mitigation, but what exactly would that look like in practice? Good luck getting open source contributors to accept any kind of liability. Except for the JiaTans of the world, who will be the first to accept it since they will have already planned to be untouchable.

Re:Timeline of the xz open source attack by patmorgan23 on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @02:07PM (#39908913)
Create an organization of paid professionals who are responsible for maintaining these libraries (and providing support to library users).

It's heartblead all over again (though those were honest mistakes, not an intentional attack

Re:Timeline of the xz open source attack by tomxor on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @01:06PM (#39908150)
> I guess that's one possible mitigation, but what exactly would that look like in practice? Good luck getting open source contributors to accept any kind of liability. Except for the JiaTans of the world, who will be the first to accept it since they will have already planned to be untouchable.

It's not necessary to accept liability, that's waived in all FOSS licenses. What I'm suggesting would only risk reputation of non-malicious contributors, and from what I've seen, most of the major FOSS contributors and maintainers freely use their real identity or associate it with their pseudonym anyway, since that attribution comes with real life perks.

Disallowing anonymous pseudonyms would raise the bar quite a bit and require more effort from attackers to construct or steal plausible looking online identities for each attack, especially when they need to hold up for a long time as with this attack.