Re:Banning Open Weight Models Would Be a Disaster
by owisd on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:24AM
(#39904110)
Property rights in general are a thing made up by people, we're just arguing over where to draw the line.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Banning Open Weight Models Would Be a Disaster
by idle_zealot on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:42AM
(#39904239)
Ideally somewhere between "you're not allowed to take my things" and "you're not allowed to learn from what I tell you".
Re:Banning Open Weight Models Would Be a Disaster
by PeterisP on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @07:34AM
(#39904556)
Not really - "arguing over where to draw the line" would be a discussion about how a hypothetical new law should treat model weights; however, assertions about whether they are a derivative work (or even "work" as such, in the sense of copyright law - noncreative transformations aren't copyrightable works, no matter how much "sweat of brow" or money they took) is a discussion about where the old copyright laws have drawn the line, and the "should's" don't matter there, it's about how the courts will interpret the precedent, and at the moment they haven't said that they are derived works, and while they could declare that, there are all kinds of arguments why they also might declare the opposite.