Re:What we know about the xz Utils backdoor that almost infe...
by Karellen on Monday April 01, 2024 @12:55PM
(#39896231)
> [libc and the kernel] currently have a much better guaranteed quality than systemd,
What are you basing that on?
Re:What we know about the xz Utils backdoor that almost infe...
by marcosdumay on Monday April 01, 2024 @01:46PM
(#39896860)
Historical behavior.
There doesn't exist anything else this could be based on.
Re:What we know about the xz Utils backdoor that almost infe...
by Karellen on Monday April 01, 2024 @02:19PM
(#39897293)
Does systemd have a historical record of its defect rate being significantly greater than that of the kernel/glibc?
I just checked Coverity scans, and the most recent defect densities appear to be:
kernel : 0.59
glibc : 0.54
systemd: 0.04
which actually looks pretty good for systemd. Is there some other analysis you're basing this off? Or are the current rates atypical, and systemd used to be a lot worse?https://scan.coverity.com/projects/linux
Re:What we know about the xz Utils backdoor that almost infe...
by dralley on Monday April 01, 2024 @02:55PM
(#39897724)
> the size of the kernel
Is mostly in the hardware support, only a tiny fraction of which is actually active. Linux has a lot of drivers, many of them are crap, but it's not obvious to me that Linux would be better off with no driver than a crap driver.
Re:What we know about the xz Utils backdoor that almost infe...
by marcosdumay on Monday April 01, 2024 @10:33PM
(#39901824)
That tiny fraction is quite huge. Filesystems and networking support are well known problematic areas, the sound system is a chapter by itself, and Linux is full of old, should-be-unused interfaces that attackers successfully use once in a while.
Besides, the core part of the kernel is way too big for anybody to read. And any of it can interact with any other part.
Absolutely yes. And also the size of the kernel.
Those two currently have a much better guaranteed quality than systemd, thus systemd is a much more pressing issue. But they don't stop being a problem just because they are not the largest one.