Re:A proposal to add signals to JavaScript
by merb on Monday April 01, 2024 @03:03AM
(#39891535)
what makes useState different than signals?!
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A proposal to add signals to JavaScript
by veidelis on Monday April 01, 2024 @04:52AM
(#39892014)
Explicit vs implicit dependencies (useEffect vs Signal.Computed/effect) and the fact that signals in contrast to useState can be used outside of react context which I assume is a good thing.
I personally mostly prefer more explicit handling of "observable values" where function signatures show which signals/observables are used inside them.
Signals are fine grained reactivity. React is coarse grained reactivity. Legend-state adds signals to React and I'd recommend it over Redux/zustand which we used to use.
Re:A proposal to add signals to JavaScript
by eyelidlessness on Monday April 01, 2024 @10:41AM
(#39894641)
They’re very similar, and you can definitely squint right to see them as fundamentally the same concept… if while squinting you also see a React component itself as a reactive effect. Which is all technically correct (the best kind), but generally not what people mean when they’re talking about signals in practical terms.