News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fast Track to Start-Up Life by untog on Thursday May 17, 2012 @03:21PM (#3988599)
Deep knowledge of general CS concepts -- the things emphasized by a good CS program -- are what allow an engineer to survive the fad-driven cycles that dominate this industry.

I don't believe so. I never studied CS at college, but have had no trouble learning new languages. I cannot write recommendation algorithms (though I'd wager that I could set up a massively parallel system using existing tools), but not every programmer needs to.

I don't doubt that a CS graduate is a better programmer than I am, but it's disingenuous to suggest that a non-CS grad will be unable to keep up with the industry. It just isn't true.

Re:The Fast Track to Start-Up Life by timr on Thursday May 17, 2012 @03:48PM (#3988723)
So you're arguing that you don't need to know anything more than a steady stream of new languages to survive? That's not a matter of belief -- there's ample evidence to the contrary. The knowledge requirements for industry programmers has been rising steadily for as long as I've been coding.

"Web developer" is today's equivalent of "Visual Basic programmer" in the early 90s. Those kinds of jobs will always exist, but they'll be increasingly marginalized -- just as they have been since the early 90s.

I expected someone to argue that university isn't necessary to learn CS. I didn't expect someone to argue that CS knowledge isn't necessary to have a career in software. Yikes. Whither hacker news?

Re:The Fast Track to Start-Up Life by mattmanser on Thursday May 17, 2012 @05:03PM (#3989089)
I can't really take anyone seriously who says a "Web developer" is today's equivalent of "Visual Basic programmer". The problem with visual basic came when people start drag dropping things together, which isn't even what rails is about.

I would also bet heavily that the number of programmming jobs needing low levels of CS knowledge but high levels of complexity management are growing at a great, great rate compared to jobs requiring high levels of CS knowledge.

Marginalized? I think not. That 20 people with a mere 8 weeks programming experience, people who will be relatively useless at programming for another year or so, are in such great demand says everything.

Re:The Fast Track to Start-Up Life by timr on Friday May 18, 2012 @07:15PM (#3994526)
"I can't really take anyone seriously who says a "Web developer" is today's equivalent of "Visual Basic programmer". The problem with visual basic came when people start drag dropping things together, which isn't even what rails is about."

That isn't what Visual Basic was "about", either. But in practice, most professional VB developers made UIs that interacted with enterprise database systems. Otherwise known as: CRUD apps.

Actually, to the extent that the vast majority of today's "web developers" are building web interfaces to a database (which they are), the tools were probably more advanced in 1990 than they are today. Hypercard and VB were far easier platforms for "programmers" with shallow CS knowledge to build enterprise systems.