News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by yummyfajitas on Thursday May 17, 2012 @10:25AM (#3987103)
How do you know your measuring device really exists?

How can I know a calculus test exists? Very easily. I look at it, feel it, etc. How can I know calculus ability exists? Again, very easily - it predicts outcomes on a set of correlated exams, the existence of which I verify with sight, touch, etc.

You seem to want to argue that education only produces vague, immaterial and unmeasurable outcomes. Lets take that as a given - in that case, why not just eliminate education spending and save $900B/year?

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by yequalsx on Thursday May 17, 2012 @11:06AM (#3987287)
Outcomes not being well defined != unnecessary or worth getting rid of.

You seem to confuse physical existence and idea. Presumably a physical object can be painted but ideas can't. Lot's of things exist that can't be verified by sight, touch, etc. In my opinion being a good teacher is not something that can be reasonably measured. I'm open to the possibility that I'm wrong but have seen no evidence that I am.