Re:Pinterest Raises $100 MM at $1.5Bn Valuation
by chucknelson on Thursday May 17, 2012 @09:48AM
(#3986924)
Agreed. We can't justify these prices by going "well, that is the perceived value by population X, so it's OK!". Sure, market forces are fine, but when market forces start to be influenced more by hype and popularity than actual business fundamentals, we should shake ourselves and snap out of it.
This has already happened so many times in different markets and the SAME market in the late 90s. I guess it's human nature to just fall in the same trap eventually? Money makes us foolish?
Re:Pinterest Raises $100 MM at $1.5Bn Valuation
by arethuza on Thursday May 17, 2012 @09:57AM
(#3986973)
"If your valuations are based on what someone else might pay in future, you are speculating"
Isn't that what angels and VCs always do then?
Re:Pinterest Raises $100 MM at $1.5Bn Valuation
by grey-area on Thursday May 17, 2012 @06:04PM
(#3989366)
Pretty much, yes, though you could argue that the best ones speculate not on what others will be prepared to pay for a company in the future, but on what they think a company could earn.
Pinterest, Instagram etc will likely never earn enough to pay back their current crazy valuations, so their valuations are the first kind of speculation, not the latter. Personally I feel Facebook is also in this group, and is overvalued right now, given their current and likely future revenue.
In a bubble (tulips, houses, stock markets) there seems to be an unending supply of greater fools, until all of a sudden there isn't, and someone (who of course expected to find some other fool to sell to) is left picking up the tab for assets which are now close to worthless.
If your valuations are based on what someone else might pay in future, you are speculating, and will be lucky if you manage to get out before other people realise the assets you have bought are not worth $1B or whatever you paid for them. If on the other hand you bought because there is a steady income stream from an investment which will eventually pay off the investment and add returns, and thus underpins the price, you don't have to worry about whether this is a bubble or not.