News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 17, 2012 @05:12AM (#3986123)
>When has someone with these qualities ever failed because he had some perceived weakness in his childhood education? //

Define "failed". Failed to get a job, too right. Failed to fit in to society, check. Failed to be happy, seems to go with the territory(!?).

Will you excuse a short aside:I'm interested in the diagnosis of a 6yo as having ADHD - what procedures and tests were performed to come to that decision. In my, albeit limited, experience of primary aged (4-11yo) boys if they're not running around half the time like some sort of sugar rushing lunatic then they're the exception to the rule. Can he sit and watch a TV show for 20 minutes without leaving to do something else?

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by ShabbyDoo on Friday May 18, 2012 @08:40PM (#3994738)
Without ADHD meds, our son often can't concentrate long enough to finish a sentence. He starts one, shifts to another, and repeats. Often, in the mornings before his meds kick-in, he lacks sufficient impulse control to avoid hitting his mother (also my wife -- the English language seems to lack a single word which denotes both relationships) or threatening her with physical violence. The differences in behavior are striking in their contrast. While I don't like the idea of "medicating away" a problem which could be solved via better parenting, I don't see how we can possibly be effective parents if we had to spend most of our time with him (1) protecting his little brother from his aggression, (2) protecting physical possessions, or (3) attempting to correct behaviors which himself seems to wish he did not have but can not stop due to lack of impulse control. On meds, we can do what normal parents get to do.
Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by btilly on Thursday May 17, 2012 @10:10AM (#3987033)
If you think that ADHD boys are running around half the time like some sort of sugar rushing lunatic then you do not know what ADHD actually is.

It is not generally a problem of too much energy and lack of focus. Rather it is a problem of inappropriate focus, frequently very intense. For instance my nephew would get so interested in whatever he was doing that he would fail to realize that he needed to pee, and then after he peed his pants he would get very upset that people were making him change his pants when he wanted to do something else.

It becomes a problem in school when children are unable to follow repeated directions because they are unaware that directions have been given, because their interest has been caught by something - anything - else.

Disclaimer: I am the parent of a 7 year old who has been identified as likely having ADHD, though I have not yet done the official screening.

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 17, 2012 @11:25AM (#3987380)
Sounds like I have ADHD.

>identified as likely having ADHD //

Yes this is the part I'm interested in, what's the diagnostic process you've gone through?

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by btilly on Thursday May 17, 2012 @11:55AM (#3987531)
He was identified as having a front lisp, so went in for speech therapy evaluation. During that evaluation he was found to have the speech impediment, and was flagged as requiring further screening for occupational therapy and ADHD. We have not yet done that screening.

My understanding is that an important part of that screening is a patient history and impressions from caregivers. Every caregiver has identified the same thing. He's plenty smart and has a great attention span for what interests him, but simply doesn't follow direction. Not in a, "kids don't listen" sort of way. But in the kind of way which causes the teacher in parent-teacher conferences to get all serious and spend the session talking about how she has more problems with him than with the rest of a class of 24 kids.

Having talked with my sister, whose son had very severe ADHD, I've been forced to admit that the symptoms fit. (My son is clearly not as severe though.) But it isn't official until he gets the official screening for it.

As for what to do about it, my sister spoke highly of cognitive therapy. She understands our resistance to drugs, had the same herself, but points out that drugs are optional and only needed as a temporary stopgap to give therapy a chance. If you don't need them to make therapy work, you don't do them. If you do need them, once therapy has progressed far enough, you can drop the drugs.

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 17, 2012 @05:17PM (#3989141)
Thanks for a full response. Really appreciated. Just one more quick question if you will:

Do you recognise yourself in the symptoms your son has, does it look like an inherited trait to you (I know that's not at all scientific). Do you have any suspicions for why this affliction might appear to be so prevalent amongst children now (other than observer bias or similar discrepancies).

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by btilly on Friday May 18, 2012 @12:02PM (#3992544)
There is definitely a hereditary component to it. And yes, the shoe might have fit for me as well.

My suspicion is that over time we're adjusting to having fewer kids and more attention/kid, and so are noticing and diagnosing problems that in previous generations went unnoticed.

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by acuozzo on Thursday May 17, 2012 @09:52AM (#3986948)
> Can he sit and watch a TV show for 20 minutes without leaving to do something else?

ADHD causes __attention_regulation__ difficulties. Many mistakenly see it as a simple lack-of-attention, but fail to realize that hyper-focus is also a common symptom.

I suggest reading the first few chapters of ``More Attention, Less Deficit'' to gain a basic understanding of ADHD.

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 17, 2012 @11:30AM (#3987402)
I'm naive about ADHD but not that naive.

I was specifically interested in the TV part rather than trying to suggest that if they could concentrate [on TV] that was asymptomatic of any disorder that might have been diagnosed.

Thanks for the reading suggestion.

At what point does ignoring people (or bodily needs, or whatever) because you're focussed [which is genuinely something I do] become "hyper focus" and how is one differentiated from the other diagnostically?