Yet I routinely hear a: "Wow, if they told it to me this way during school I might have cared!" or "It really made my head smoke, but it felt good."
The truth is that we should look to the best when teaching and we would be stupid if we didn't. And the best are people like 3blue1brown. If your class falls significantly below such a level of clarity and engagement it will suck. During my own math education I had teachers that left out the most fundamental applications. E.g. something like an integral has clear applications, it is a new super power with which you can solve new problems — yet all we did was learning a receipe and solving abstract problems. The fact that it was a super power was something I had to figure out myself, later.
And this was common. I even was lucky because I had a good physics teacher who managed to being up a lot of what we learned in math and give it a more practical feel, but most of my friends from other schools were not so lucky.
No it didn't. I am very confident it did not. All students that make it past grade school go through nearly the exact same sequence and motivating examples beginning from geometry, high school algebra, and then some introduction to calculus if not calculus outright.
And the motivating example has always been how to calculate area, and if advanced enough, volume, for all kinds of shapes, regular or otherwise. This is not a recent development, its been the motivating example and the entire purpose for calculus having been invented.
I am so confident in this that I am here to call you a terrible student and that, yes, you likely were a terrible student, especially since your characterization is the exact standard excuse I hear from terrible students.
So now I have to drill - what was "nonsensical"? What had "zero context"? You immediately have lost the claim of "zero application", so we don't have to go there.
If your claim is beyond K-12 math and into university, then I would be too upset to even argue with you if that is your actual position. Making these claims after more than a decade of learning math tells me you have trained yourself to forget all you learned.
The first fact I want to have written down is that there are bad math teachers. And sadly it is not uncommon for them to be bad, as I mentioned most of my collegues from other classes and schools had bad math teachers and some of them were people that liked math.
Now as an educator I am aware that students are quick to blame other people or the system for their own deficiencies, but I can tell you for a fact that our math teacher failed to explain us what an integral was actually for in an parsable way, even after multiple times of asking. She just knew how to do the formula stuff, she never used it herself on real applications. And when she did explain things, she always did it once, much too briefly in the beginning, so that by the point at which we started doing her always decidedly abstract examples nobody knew what the fuck this was for. As I said, our physics and mechanica teachers were better math teachers than her. As for the integral I had to go and look it up myself, the internet was still young and there weren't many grown ups who knew how to look such a thing up and when I saw the explainations I wondered why nobody ever told us..?
I understand btw. why it can be an advantage to understand math in purely abstract ways, but in her case she just didn't want to talk much and stick to the examples. And that is bad teaching. Ah and before we get into a discussion about specifics, like many on this site I grew up and live happily outside of the US, so educational plans etc. might differ.
I don't think its hard to find something interesting about math either, and it is immediately applicable, even with what I think is extremely stupid in the form of common core as presented in the USA, you are literally being presented story problems about common every day occurrences and activities.