News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by peterhunt on Thursday May 17, 2012 @04:26AM (#3986005)
I agree with this, but just because a doctor loses a patient once in a while doesn't mean that we should give up on medicine.
Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by jkn on Thursday May 17, 2012 @06:26AM (#3986283)
This is not a correct analogy to "bad information is worse than no information".

A better analogy would be a medicine that typically leaves patients worse off than they were before treatment.

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by Natsu on Friday May 18, 2012 @03:13AM (#3990727)
Doctors have a maxim of "first do no harm." I believe that maxim is being violated by some of these attempted fixes.

I'm not saying they should give up the search for something that works, but they absolutely should not cause harm just for the sake of doing something.

Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by DougBTX on Thursday May 17, 2012 @05:34AM (#3986176)
What if the test makes good doctors quit? (As seems to be the case here.)
Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by peterhunt on Thursday May 17, 2012 @05:41AM (#3986195)
I don't think that this really fits into my analogy, but if losing a few good teachers is the price we need to pay for preventing a toxic culture of no-accountability where administrators are not allowed to make metrics-based decisions then so be it.
Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by kbolino on Thursday May 17, 2012 @07:35AM (#3986473)
If you have the wrong metrics, you cannot make the right decisions. If you are throwing away good teachers because the rest are really good at gaming the tests then you have done far more harm than good.
Re:Meet the ‘worst’ 8th grade math teacher in NYC by Natsu on Sunday May 20, 2012 @12:01AM (#3997897)
The analysis shows that the test results contain zero information, unless you believe that teachers change quality randomly every year. If correlation begins to appear in those evaluations, it will be because the test has been gamed.