News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Pentagon's Silicon Valley Problem by sequoia on Thursday March 28, 2024 @10:42AM (#39852182)
> at least twenty-two thousand people, some 70 percent of them women and children.

People are definitely dying and that includes civilians, but facts matter and a lot of these numbers are simply made up by Hamas. Here's some analysis that demonstrates that it's extremely unlikely Hamas's Gaza Health Ministry numbers are based in reality: https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/how-gaza-he...

Stuff like almost perfectly linear growth of deaths over days and so on, take a look at the article.

This is also Hamas who claims that every person killed was a civilian. Try to find "number of Hamas combatants killed" in the Gaza Health Ministry numbers, they don't even count this. Isn't that a bit weird? Israel will tell you how many people killed were armed soldiers and how many were civilians, as most places will do.

I don't know why people believe the numbers coming from Hamas. I wish there were a more reliable source in the area, but believing Hamas because you have no other numbers to go on is plain stupid.

Re:The Pentagon's Silicon Valley Problem by enterprise_cog on Thursday March 28, 2024 @09:04PM (#39859439)
This piece makes a series of assumptions, with no proof those assumptions are true, then says the Gaza Health Ministry must be lying because the numbers don't match the assumptions. That isn't how statistics work.

"One would expect quite a bit of variation day to day. In fact, the daily reported casualty count over this period averages 270 plus or minus about 15%. This is strikingly little variation. There should be days with twice the average or more and others with half or less. Perhaps what is happening is the Gaza ministry is releasing fake daily numbers that vary too little because they do not have a clear understanding of the behavior of naturally occurring numbers."

Why would you expect that? Why isn't the number of munitions dropped on Gaza plotted with this data if that is the case? Why isn't it simply that an overloaded and besieged health care system can only process a certain amount of deaths per day? "Unfortunately, verified control data is not available to formally test this conclusion" indeed.

"The Gaza Health Ministry has consistently claimed that about 70% of the casualties are women or children. This total is far higher than the numbers reported in earlier conflicts with Israel."

Israel is trying to kill civilians and Gaza has a large population of women and children.

"The daily number of women casualties should be highly correlated with the number of non-women and non-children (i.e., men) reported."

Why should this be the case? It is more likely that Israel is targeting women and children at a higher rate than men.

"Another red flag, raised by Salo Aizenberg and written about extensively, is that if 70% of the casualties are women and children and 25% of the population is adult male, then either Israel is not successfully eliminating Hamas fighters or adult male casualty counts are extremely low. This by itself strongly suggests that the numbers are at a minimum grossly inaccurate and quite probably outright faked. Finally, on Feb. 15, Hamas admitted to losing 6,000 of its fighters, which represents more than 20% of the total number of casualties reported."

So they look a less than one month time frame (10/26-11/10), assumed all the deaths there are still the total now in March, then state that Hamas lost 6k troops in Feb and that makes the numbers invalid. That makes no logical sense. Obviously more people have died, likely over 100k. Sadly, Israel has devastated the health system in Gaza so numbers can't be accurately reported. So given 100k total dead, 6k dead fighters is 6% of the casualties. Which does point to the fact that Israel is targeting civilians and that they are ineffective in eliminating Hamas.

Then they have these gems:

"Are there better numbers? Some objective commentators have acknowledged Hamas’ numbers in previous battles with Israel to be roughly accurate. Nevertheless, this war is wholly unlike its predecessors in scale or scope; international observers who were able to monitor previous wars are now completely absent, so the past can’t be assumed to be a reliable guide. The fog of war is especially thick in Gaza, making it impossible to quickly determine civilian death totals with any accuracy."

Why are there no observers? Israel refuses to let them in because they are doing a genocide.

"Not only do official Palestinian death counts fail to differentiate soldiers from children, but Hamas also blames all deaths on Israel even if caused by Hamas’ own misfired rockets, accidental explosions, deliberate killings, or internal battles."

al-Ahli has been shown to not be a Hamas rocket.[0] Of course, Israel pivoted on that and started to say every hospital was a Hamas C2 headquarters, makes it harder to prove they are lying.

"One group of researchers at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health compared Hamas reports to data on UNRWA workers. They argued that because the death rates were approximately similar, Hamas’ numbers must not be inflated. But their argument relied on a crucial and unverified assumption: that UNRWA workers are not disproportionately more likely to be killed than the general population. That premise exploded when it was uncovered that a sizable fraction of UNRWA workers are affiliated with Hamas. Some were even exposed as having participated in the Oct. 7 massacre itself."

This argument, outside of being misleading with regard to "a sizable fraction of UNRWA workers" (even Israel's fake numbers said 10%), does nothing to "explode" the premise. Hamas has military groups and government (civilian) groups. Of course people involved in the aid distribution might be involved in the government. That doesn't mean they are armed combatants nor that they would be killed more than other civilians.

In short, this is a propaganda piece with a veneer of statistics to try and obfuscate that fact.

[0] https://forensic-architecture.org/investigation/israeli-disi...

Re:The Pentagon's Silicon Valley Problem by sequoia on Saturday March 30, 2024 @06:37PM (#39879362)
I won’t argue with this commenter because they are clearly beyond reason, but I’d like to point out a couple things to anyone reading along. This commenter demonstrates a couple traits common to many (not all) Palestine activists: a deep disconnection from factual reality and the willingness to claim and/or believe anything that discredits Israel, no matter how nonsensical the claim.

Look for example in this post, where cog accuses Israel of doing things that don’t make sense for Israel to do, and accuses Hamas of doing things that don’t make sense for Hamas to do.

- “Israel is targeting women and children at a higher rate than men” even if you think Israel is demonic, why would they do this, go out of their way to spare men? This doesn’t make sense.

- “Obviously more people have died, likely over 100k.” So according to this commenter, Hamas is underreporting deaths by a factor of 3. Why would they do this? Hamas has an incentive to over-report deaths to increase the anger at Israel; why would they underreport them by 3x? Again, this assertion makes absolutely no sense.

So these assertions make no sense, but it doesn’t matter to Palestine activists like the one above. They’ll repeat anything that directs blame at Israel, no matter how outlandish. You could say Israel is launching gazan civilians into low orbit and they’d repeat your claim because it casts Israel as evil.

Above, we see that even Hamas’s own Gazan death toll numbers are unsatisfactory for some Palestine activists who regard the numbers as too low and therefor not “critical enough” of Israel. So what does the commenter above do? Make up his own number, 3x higher than Hamas’s own claims, right in front of us. Facts don’t matter here, the argument is purely in the realm of emotion and fantasy.

I hope we can reach a place where we reject histrionics and lying, acknowledge the complexity of the situation in Israel, and work towards a lasting peace for all involved. Making up wild and nonsensical accusations to promote the demonization of Israelis does not help anyone, it certainly doesn’t help Gazans.

Re:The Pentagon's Silicon Valley Problem by tptacek on Saturday March 30, 2024 @07:20PM (#39879614)
The thing to do when you feel like a commenter is "beyond reason" is to flag the comment. Writing a long response to what you feel is an unreasonable or bad-faith comment is just feeding the toxicity. The abyss is commenting back into you, so to speak.

You can see the effect here: in trying to compose a reply to the parent comment, you managed to violate a variety of HN guidelines yourself.

Re:The Pentagon's Silicon Valley Problem by sequoia on Monday April 01, 2024 @10:39AM (#39894614)
Ah OK. I didn't realize I was violating guidelines. I'll try flagging in the future.

I thought there was some utility to analyzing the comment because it's characteristic of much of the rhetoric on this topic and it seemed like a good "teachable moment." But point taken.

Re:The Pentagon's Silicon Valley Problem by enterprise_cog on Monday April 01, 2024 @11:33AM (#39895237)
Flagging is supposed to be used for posts that go against the guidelines, not something you disagree with.
Re:The Pentagon's Silicon Valley Problem by tptacek on Monday April 01, 2024 @12:21PM (#39895844)
Yes.
Re:The Pentagon's Silicon Valley Problem by runarberg on Saturday March 30, 2024 @07:59PM (#39879884)
I’d like to note that it is not Hamas which is reporting the official death count, it is the Gaza Health Ministry. While the ministry is under the control of Hamas, the actual reporting is done by actual public health professionals, doctors, etc. who may be Hamas members simply as means of occupation. So Hamas is not under reporting anything.

Second, the methodology of the reporting is a lower bound. They compile a list of names who health-care workers (doctors, nurses, etc.) confirm dead. This list is very credible, as you can cross reference the names with the Israeli controlled Gaza population registry, you can find real people behind those names, with social media profiles, obituaries, etc. This methodology has been proven to be accurate in previous wars. This is still a lower bound, because there are still around 7000 people missing and presumed dead. This number is harder to estimate because this may actually include double counting, and false positives (e.g. successfully fled over the border). It may also be an under count as there are cases of entire families being bombed at the same time with nobody left to report them missing. Your parent’s 100 000 is not realistic, but around 40 000 is not an unrealistic estimate (the 100 000 is used to described the sum of dead + missing + injured, so perhaps this was a simple mistake by your parent).

And finally the statistical methodology of the article you cited earlier is—to but it bluntly—pseudostatistical crap. The your parent was correct in pointing out that the assumptions based in that article are never sufficiently justified to proof an abnormality. This is actually from the playbook of Trump election denialism, where the distribution of votes was somehow proof of tampering. Here the distribution of reported death is not proof of any abnormality. This article you cited has actually been submitted and flagged, submitted and flagged repeatedly here on HN. The HN community has weighted that article and deemed it unfitting. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39684474)