News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by dsrguru on Wednesday May 16, 2012 @10:32PM (#3985078)
"My guess is that the direct good effect will be bigger than the direct harm."

Did rms just admit that proprietary software can theoretically have benefits? What's this world coming to lol

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by Mizza on Wednesday May 16, 2012 @10:39PM (#3985094)
RMS is pretty reasonable! He gets a bad rap, I think. It's like people watch his every move like, "Oh man, what's that craaaazzyyy old man going to do next?" Of course, he's actually right 4 times out of 5.

I thought the point he made in this article was a balanced one.

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by dsrguru on Thursday May 17, 2012 @12:53AM (#3985499)
I agree that he was pretty reasonable in the case of this article, but he is a bit crazy by most people's standards. A friend of mine has worked for the FSF and told me that Stallman won't even use the World Wide Web! Anything he needs looked up he has coworkers do for him because they're foolish enough to trust that nonfree web sites aren't malicious.
Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by koeselitz on Thursday May 17, 2012 @12:57AM (#3985507)
It's not strictly true that he only has other people do it for him:

http://article.gmane.org/gmane.os.openbsd.misc/134979

As far as the internet, though, as I told a friend long ago - Richard Stallman doesn't need the internet. The internet needs Richard Stallman.

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by dsrguru on Thursday May 17, 2012 @01:20AM (#3985559)
He posted that to a newsgroup, not the Web. I'm sure he wasn't using the Web to do that, especially given the content of that post!
Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by jiggy2011 on Wednesday May 16, 2012 @10:56PM (#3985148)
That surprised me as well, I'm sure I've heard him say before that nonfree software is 100% unethical even on a free platform.

Perhaps he realises that having steam + valve games would be a huge net win for desktop linux use.

Even if you had mainly nonfree software , in theory desktop linux would still be quite a free system in the sense that there would be a level playing field amongst software devs.

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by dsrguru on Wednesday May 16, 2012 @11:05PM (#3985171)
Actually, that does seem to fit with the rational behind the LGPL. If you're going to write free software that replicates a proprietary program or library's functionality without adding anything new, rms believes you should make it available to the widest possible audience with the hope that more contributions will trickle back. However, I'm also sure I've heard him say that nonfree software is unequivocally unethical even on a free platform. Hell, didn't he say recently something about not being able to justify using proprietary medical equipment to save his life unless he immediately would embark on a quest to produce a free equivalent? Maybe he makes a distinction between trying to free future adopters from total proprietariness (i.e. in the case of games and LGPL'd libraries) versus trying to make people who have already taken the red pill 100% free.
Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by nknight on Thursday May 17, 2012 @12:39AM (#3985460)
Even the most zealous are rarely devoid of all nuance.

Note he actually says "Nonfree games (like other nonfree programs) are unethical". That one believes an act is unethical is different from believing it will have a net negative effect vs not performing the act, and there's often a lot of nuance to be had when something is ethically questionable.

Consider the periodically-raised question of taking control of a botnet in order to shut it down. Opinions on this range from "totally ethical" to "totally unethical", even as much of the "totally unethical" crowd would probably admit that shutting down the botnet is a net good vs not doing so.

Sometimes, "X is unethical" doesn't mean "no good will come of X", it means "we need a third option". RMS believes non-free software is unethical, almost surely believes the existence of software in general is a net good, and that Free Software is the "third option".

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by jiggy2011 on Thursday May 17, 2012 @12:50AM (#3985491)
I don't think I've ever read an argument suggesting that shutting down a botnet (as long as that is all you do) would be unethical, more that it would technically be illegal.

I'm sure I've heard Stallman say in the past that software cannot possibly be in any way good unless it is free.

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by pippy on Thursday May 17, 2012 @12:15AM (#3985382)
Programmers have to eat, and free software needs a supporting paradigm to be sustainable. With Firefox it's the search engine, with Apache it's support, only smaller projects can be made from pure passion. Any large company porting software to a platform will be good, as more people (and thus support) will come to Linux.

>Nonfree games (like other nonfree programs) are unethical because they deny freedom to their users

I get the feeling he lives in a fantasy world. Unethical is hitting a baby in the face, not allowing people to see how you wrote a computer programme.

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by dsrguru on Thursday May 17, 2012 @12:49AM (#3985486)
Well, I'm certainly grateful that his views are this strong, or else there wouldn't have been a free software movement for the open source movement to arise out of. If you think about it, the world as we know it would be completely different without Stallman. However, I'm not quite sure I agree with his belief that the existence of proprietary software licenses that tell you not to share with your neighbor create a double bind in which you either comply with the license and contribute to the destruction of social cohesion or you help your neighbor but incur psychosocial harm in the form of guilt that shouldn't be. :)
Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by jiggy2011 on Thursday May 17, 2012 @12:46AM (#3985472)
Just because you are not doing something directly and obviously "evil" like hitting a baby does not mean something cannot be unethical.

As more of our world is software and we rely on it to do things like store our personal information and trust it to respect our privacy etc, how is the availability and ability to understand and inspect that software not a potentially very ethical issue?

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by pippy on Thursday May 17, 2012 @08:58PM (#3989887)
Yes you're right. I was trying to frame ethics in its popular definition. I personally love and support open source projects, as they are better from a moral standpoint.

Proprietary software isn't a really bad thing, comparing it to say murder or thievery. If you had to choose between doing the wrong thing (which isn't that bad) and not eating, most people would do the wrong thing.

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by AJ007 on Thursday May 17, 2012 @01:02AM (#3985517)
I would agree that DRM that breaks basic functions of an OS is unethical. I believe that DRM that prevents a user from using or accessing something for which he or she has paid for, at any time in the future for any reason, is unethical and legally dubious.

The free or nonfreeness of a particular piece of software is as much of a moral question as the color of sand on a beach.

Re:Nonfree DRM'd Games on GNU/Linux: Good or Bad? by dsrguru on Thursday May 17, 2012 @01:27AM (#3985581)
But if you believe that DRM which "prevents a user from using or accessing something for which he or she has paid for, at any time in the future for any reason, is unethical and legally dubious," why don't you believe the same about nonfree software programs that meet the quoted criteria? Or are you saying proprietary software is okay if and only if its license is not enforced? Actually, the more I think about that the more I think I agree with it.