News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why x86 doesnt need to die by snvzz on Thursday March 28, 2024 @03:18AM (#39848530)
>As ChipsAndCheese points out, the uArch diagrams of modern high-performance ARM and x86 cores look very similar.

So far so good.

>And the real answer, is that both designs are neither RISC or CISC

This is... Not even wrong.

>(the fact that one implements a CISC-derived ISA and the other implements a RISC-like ISA is irrelevant to the actual microarchtecture).

Exactly. CISC and RISC are characteristics of the ISA, not the microarchitecture.

But note (and I can't stress this enough), this does not mean ISA doesn't matter.

The ISA is the interface between software and hardware. A well designed ISA will e.g.:

- Not restrict the actual design of the microarchitecture.

- Not expose microarchitecture artifacts.

- Not force unjustified complexity into the microarchitecture nor the software.

Re:Why x86 doesnt need to die by fanf2 on Thursday March 28, 2024 @07:17AM (#39849753)
Yes, good points.

It’s worth remembering that the surviving CISC architectures (x86 and z/370) are less CISCy than VAX and 68k were, in terms of number of address operands and complexity of addressing modes. And ARM is not a classically RISCy RISC. Instruction sets seem to have converged on a pragmatic middle ground β€” except for RISCV :-)

Re:Why x86 doesnt need to die by snvzz on Thursday March 28, 2024 @07:53AM (#39850064)
>except for RISCV :-)

Oh, it also is (very) pragmatic. It's just the sort of pragmatism culture that from the outside gets often misunderstood as "purism" :-)