Re:First practical SHA-256 collision for 31 steps. fse2024
by maxcoder4 on Wednesday March 27, 2024 @11:07AM
(#39840266)
Birthday attach is a real attack and often useful in practice. "Just use brute force" is a huge oversimplification, but the SO link explains it in more detail.
One time pad is not a hash algorithm so obviously a generic attack on a collision function doesn't apply to it.
That Stack Exchange answer also immediately set off alarm bells in my head because it pretends to be entirely generic, but the obvious thing to do with entirely generic cryptographic intuitions is apply them to the One Time Pad and check their answers work. This intuition doesn't work. Even if you could try all the possible keys you learn nothing, because of the hand-waving about "plausible" plaintext.