Re:Judge Alsup learns to code and schools Oracle
by scott_w on Friday May 18, 2012 @07:33AM
(#3991288)
I don't dispute your statement.
My point is specifically related to Oracle's claim that Android couldn't have shipped without a rangeCheck() function, which is patently nonsense.
Re:Judge Alsup learns to code and schools Oracle
by ZeroGravitas on Monday May 21, 2012 @07:21AM
(#4002290)
My point is that it's worse than nonsense, it's actually arguing the opposite of the truth. The "copying", rather than speeding up Android development to Google's benefit, actually slowed Android development in an attempt to help OpenJDK/Oracle.
That this is the only direct copyright infringement they could find is highly ironic, but I guess either the lawyers didn't understand the subtleties here, or thought the jury wouldn't as this argument wasn't made (except obliquely in Bloch's statements).
Bashing it out cowboy style would have been faster and in no way harmed Android. It's Oracle's codebase he was spending time and energy improving with good engineering practice.