Re:Visualization 'demonic' face distortions in a case of pro...
by heavyset_go on Saturday March 23, 2024 @12:49PM
(#39801255)
I'd assume someone suffering from this condition has spent time and money on doctors to address it, suggesting that they're being earnest about their experiences and perceptions versus someone taking a researcher for a ride.
I'd also assume that they were referred by a doctor who is both familiar with the patient and with research into the condition.
Re:Visualization 'demonic' face distortions in a case of pro...
by verisimi on Saturday March 23, 2024 @01:15PM
(#39801456)
Exactly. It's impossible to validate that this is really the illusion that the patient is seeing (which is highly unlikely to me) versus the possibility that the patient is making all this up (highly likely).
I also wonder, how the patient was able to confirm the face was deformed correctly if they genuinely have this condition. If they are looking at an already deformed image, that image will be further deformed, no? The deformation 'filter' will be applied to the image too...
Re:Visualization 'demonic' face distortions in a case of pro...
by ajuc on Saturday March 23, 2024 @01:24PM
(#39801515)
> I also wonder, how the patient was able to confirm the face was deformed correctly
That's mentioned in the article - this particular patient only has that problem IRL, not when looking at screens or drawings.
But the journal link does not discuss how the researcher rejects the hypothesis that the individual could be fabricating the experience. It could also be the case that the researcher helped fabricate the results to produce work - a risk created in part by the unending pressure of publish/perish.
Obviously it would be very unfair to assume that either patient or researcher are deceptive here, given that it's far more likely that both patient and researcher simply want to help people with this condition. I do not want to call the researcher into question, and much less do I want to invalidate the patient's experience.
But I'm curious about how we should approach this with healthy skepticism in the age of the replicability crisis - what specific signals do you use to confirm the likely veracity of the researcher and subject, given the very subjective and unblinded nature of the case study, and lack of discussion on how we discard the deceptive hypothesis? Did you find details that I'm missing? And if you assign a percentage to your confidence in this result, what percentage is it, and why?